It wouldn't be Kevin Keating's fault if he has missed the simmering scandal that is and remains the creation of Giuliani within the Administration for Children's Services. The media has done a pretty good job so far of protecting Rudy, his successor, and their accomplices. Do I know whereof I speak?
I am a ten year veteran child protective worker with eight years in the Emergency Children's Services section of Division of Child Protective Services. Being of perhaps the last generation that was taught critical thinking in public school and having been raised with a social consciousness I was impelled to be a whistle blower in ACS, though so far not too successful a one.
I'm not here just to toot my own horn, push my own agenda, monopolize your board or advertise a commercial web site but those who want to know more about this aspect of what was and still is Giuliani Time should take a peek at my blog www.fatoldjewishguywholivesintheprojects.com.
I look forward to seeing the movie and hope I can possibly make a contribution to the task at hand of stopping Giuliani's national ambitions.
http://mediamatters.org/items/200605030011
Fineman joined Matthews in
Summary: On MSNBC's Hardball, host Chris Matthews and Newsweek
chief political correspondent Howard Fineman praised former New York
City Mayor Rudy Giuliani and Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) while speculating
on their potential as Republican candidates in the 2008 presidential
race. Matthews said of Giuliani: "He looks like [a] president to me."
When Matthews called a potential McCain-Giuliani ticket something for
"Democrats ... to go home and worry about," Fineman agreed that it
would be like "Starsky and Hutch."
On the May 2 edition of MSNBC's Hardball, host Chris Matthews and
Newsweek chief political correspondent Howard Fineman praised former
New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani and Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) while
speculating on their potential as Republican candidates in the 2008
presidential race. After playing a clip of Giuliani discussing whether
he would run for president, Matthews stated, "He looks like [a]
president to me." When Matthews called a potential McCain-Giuliani
ticket something for "Democrats ... to go home and worry about,"
Fineman agreed that it would be like "Starsky and Hutch," the cop duo
from the television series and movie of the same name. Fineman added
that a McCain-Giuliani ticket would be "culturally diverse." In an
apparent reference to McCain's Vietnam War service as a naval aviator
and Giuliani's past work as a U.S. attorney, Matthews later stated:
"Remember the great Churchill speech, 'We will fight them in the air.
We will fight them in the streets.' You can do it with McCain in the
air and Giuliani in the streets."
Chuck Todd, editor in chief of the National Journal's weblog, The
Hotline, later cited Giuliani's association with former New York City
police commissioner Bernard Kerik -- who withdrew his nomination as
secretary of Homeland Security amid scandal allegations -- as an
obstacle to Giuliani's purported presidential ambitions. Although
Matthews acknowledged that Kerik "had a little love nest going on near
the World Trade Center," he shrugged off the political significance of
Giuliani's association with Kerik, citing it as "proof of how enduring
[Giuliani] is, because that didn't hurt him."
From the May 2 edition of MSNBC's Hardball with Chris Matthews:
MATTHEWS: Rudy Giuliani was in Iowa campaigning for congressional
candidates the other day, and he answered some questions about whether
he will run for president in 2008.
GIULIANI [video clip]: I've got a lot of places to go and a lot of
people to talk to, and, you know, a long process of figuring out
whether, you know, it makes sense to run for president in 2008. I
don't know the answer to that yet.
MATTHEWS: He looks like president to me, Chuck.
TODD: You know, I'll tell you, I have been in this camp that says
he's not going to run. They say there's no way he's going to run. This
has been a marketing campaign to help his businesses.
[...]
MATTHEWS: OK. Let me give the Democrats something to go home and
worry about, including the moderate Democrats, and the conservative
Democrats and the liberals, of course. McCain-Giuliani, the ticket.
FINEMAN: Starsky and Hutch.
MATTHEWS: Does that scare -- that may carry Pennsylvania, New
York. It could carry California, that ticket.
FINEMAN: It's culturally diverse but tough on the war.
MATTHEWS: Both hawks.
FINEMAN: And they are both hawks, but, you know, one is a cop and
one is a military guy. It's not quite the same thing. But the way
George Bush and Karl Rove have defined the presidency, they have
defined it as a war commander-tough cop in the world presidency.
Ironically, these two guys -- I don't know if it's ironically or on
purpose -- these two guys fit it best.
And my theory is that Rudy is going to do everything he can up to
running, up to jumping in the squad car and running. It's going to be
dependent on what happens with McCain. Because my sense from some of
the people around Rudy that I know, and some of the McCain people, is
that they both think there isn't enough shelf space for both of them
as presidential candidates. And I think Rudy is going to look to see
if McCain stumbles. If McCain doesn't, I don't think Rudy will run.
Maybe he'll be on the ticket.
MATTHEWS: How about the veep?
FINEMAN: Well, that's a separate question. That comes later.
MATTHEWS: It's an attractive position.
FINEMAN: Well sure. And by the way, he can also say, "I'm not
going to run, and how are you going to decorate the mahogany for my
not-running?"
MATTHEWS: What's that mean?
FINEMAN: That means putting the money on the table. As long as
we're talking -- that's an old Bronx term.
[crosstalk]
TODD: I've got two words: Bernie Kerik. How many Bernie Keriks
does Rudy Giuliani have to go through?
MATTHEWS: That's the guy he put up for the Homeland Security, it
turns out they had a little love nest going on near the World Trade
Center. But, you know, that's proof of how enduring he is, because
that didn't hurt him.
TODD: We haven't vetted --
FINEMAN: Also there's a whole documentary about Rudy that's
dynamite. It's going to get a lot of airtime.
TODD: Rudy was the most hated man in New York City on September 10th [2001].
FINEMAN: It's just the whole picture of the rest of Rudy Giuliani.
MATTHEWS: Remember the great Churchill speech, "We will fight them
in the air. We will fight them in the streets." You can do it with
McCain in the air and Giuliani in the streets.
CBS NEWS
What Does Future Hold For 9/11 Icon?
NEW YORK, May 2, 2006(CBS) By CBSNews.com's Scott Conroy.
Of all the potential Republican candidates for president in 2008, Rudy Giuliani would surely be counted among those that Democratic frontrunner Hillary Clinton would least like to face.
The former mayor of New York emerged as a national hero following the Sept. 11 terror attacks, and he appeals to the same independent voters that Clinton must win over if she wants to move back into 1600 Pennsylvania Ave.
Giuliani, who has maintained a fairly low political profile, took a big step out of the presidential closet on Monday with a well-publicized trip to Iowa, where he huddled with GOP leaders and donors.
"I am interested in public service again," he said. "My effort this year will be to help Republicans get elected and, quite honestly, a part of it also is saying to myself, 'Does it look like I have a chance in 2008?'"
But Giuliani has a troubling problem. How does he get the GOP's base — the conservative voters who turn out in droves for Republican primaries — to support him?
Two schools of thoughts have emerged regarding Giuliani's presidential ambitions.
The first line of thinking is prominent among experts inside the Beltway, who maintain that Giuliani is in an untenable position and, realizing that, will eventually decide not to run.
Giuliani knows his liberal social views would make it nearly impossible for him to become the Republican nominee, they say. Conventional wisdom holds that a pro-choice, pro-gay rights, anti-gun New Yorker would have about as much of a chance ingratiating himself with South Carolina's Republican primary voters as Hillary Clinton.
Giuliani is making millions from his law firm, consulting company and speaking engagements, and he will be content to live out the rest of his days in private life, basking in the wealth and iconic status, or so this thinking goes.
"I'm in the camp that assumes he's not running," Hotline Editor Chuck Todd told CBSNews.com. "I think it's a marketing ploy for his business."
"His poll standing is that of a celebrity, not a political leader," American Conservative Union Chairman David Keene added.
But an enormous ego may be the single most important character trait for someone who wants to be president, a quality that no one who knows him accuses Giuliani of lacking. Two men who have written books about Giuliani have a positive view of his potential to become the next president.
"Rudy Giuliani has wanted to be president since he was a child,” said WCBS-TV political reporter Andrew Kirtzman. “His first childhood hero was John F. Kennedy, and he's always wanted to emulate his achievement as a Catholic president, and there is no sign that that initiative has ever abated."
Kirtzman's book, "Rudy Giuliani: Emperor of the City," covers Giuliani's career through 2001.
Presidential ambition is one thing, but reality is another. The big question is this: How can Giuliani connect with conservative voters? According to Kirtzman, the answer has a lot to do with the image that he has cultivated for himself.
"From what I've seen, conservatives really relate on a visceral level — in a positive way — to Giuliani because he's so personally associated with toughness, both in his foreign policy ideology and when it comes to his record fighting crime in the city,” Kirtzman said. “Put yourself in Giuliani's place. You're just mobbed by adoring fans wherever you go. You walk into a restaurant and the restaurant erupts in cheers. Every trip to the grocery store involves worshipful fans telling you they want you to run for president. It gives you a very strong sense that this could happen."
Giuliani's fledgling campaign has proceeded on two tracks. He has energetically amassed political IOUs by appearing at GOP fundraisers and campaigning for Republican candidates around the country.
And he has bypassed conservative leaders — who view him with suspicion — by appealing directly to the grassroots conservative voters who will play a major role in deciding the GOP's 2008 presidential nominee.
For the past three years or so, Giuliani has been a headliner at "Get Motivated" seminars organized by an evangelical Christian and GOP stalwart named Peter Lowe.
The seminars are traveling infomercials that often play in sold-out arenas around the country. They feature speakers who offer advice on how to achieve success in the stock market, real estate and general strategies on how seminar-goers can improve their lives.
Amid a storm of applause, falling confetti and the strains of Frank Sinatra's “New York, New York,” Giuliani strides on the stage to deliver his stump speech on the principles of leadership.
The audiences are largely composed of the God-fearing Republican voters Giuliani needs to win over to capture the GOP nomination. These seminars have enabled him to connect with hundreds of thousands of people across the country.
"Giuliani was not a conventional candidate when he ran for mayor, he was not a conventional mayor and he's not going to be conventional now," said Fred Siegel, who wrote, “The Prince of the City: Giuliani, New York, and the Genius of American Life,” a book about Giuliani's eight years as mayor.
In January, Giuliani made a direct gesture to the Christian right by addressing a group of evangelical leaders at the Global Pastures Network in Florida. When Giuliani was asked whether he will run for president, he replied, "Only God knows."
Giuliani is scheduled to headline a fundraiser on May 28 for Ralph Reed, the former Christian Coalition leader who is running for Lieutenant Governor in Georgia — another indication that he is getting more serious about plotting his presidential path.
America's Mayor has some formidable assets. He is the most popular figure in national politics, according to a recent Quinnipiac poll. And money is no problem. The millions of dollars he has made since he left office in 2001 have put him in a very strong position financially. His advisers also are quick to point out that Giuliani would have no trouble attracting major campaign donors if he decides to run.
But Giuliani's road to the GOP nomination would seem to be paved with misfortune. It's generally believed that a Republican setback in the upcoming congressional election would make the party more likely to turn to a candidate with his moderate social views. (Giuliani says he'll announce his decision after the November election.)
It is also thought that another national tragedy — a major terrorist attack or a Katrina-style disaster — could well make the former New York mayor the frontrunner for the GOP nomination and perhaps the presidency as well.
Failing such developments — one of them bad for Republicans, the other devastating for the nation — Giuliani figures to remain a long-shot candidate.
The Manhattan Institute wasn't just Giuliani's cheering section or
party-giver, they were the influential and connected think tank that
created his candidacy, ideas, and policies.
Giuliani will quickly jettison his so-called pro-gay and pro-choice
credentials if it suits his megolomanic quest for power, just as he
dumped his wife on television.
I saw a picture of Giuliani down South at some right wing
religious-political convention this year, and he was going off like an
inspired preacher.
Enzo Titolo
http://www.enzotitolo.blogspot.com
With someone riddled with flaws like RWG, how do you begin to paint a
comprehensive picture of the man? I just hope people don't let the
messenger's own record get in the way of the message. Keating is brave
to take on the subject. But I think people will react the same way as
if David Duke had done an "expose" of Jesse Jackson.
[NOTE: The Manhattan Institute, the right wing think tank that threw
Giuliani the party described below, was founded by CIA director
William Casey and funded by Chase Bank and pharmaceutical companies
connected to eugenics. It has many direct links to Bush, Enron and the
war in Iraq.]
http://www.observer.com/20060501/20060501_Jason_Horowitz_pageone_newsstory1.asp
NY Observer 4/26/06
Can Rudy Pass
As Republican?
Hillary Helps
By Jason Horowitz
Freshly returned from the midterm campaign trail, a smiling Rudy
Giuliani was welcomed into the friendly confines of Cipriani's on the
evening of April 25. As waiters in white coats scurried about the main
dining room, Mr. Giuliani made an entrance worthy of a Presidential
contender.
"I've spent a lot of time down in the South," he told The Observer as
he walked in with his wife Judith on his arm. "I just got back from
New Orleans. It was devastating, but I'm back in New York. I love New
York. I'm from New York."
The black-tie affair, thrown by the Manhattan Institute, Mr.
Giuliani's old cheering section, marked a homecoming of sorts for the
61-year-old former Mayor. During the last several months, he has spent
a lot of time under the radar and below the Mason-Dixon Line, quietly
building coalitions with conservative Republicans as he prepares for a
potential 2008 Presidential bid.
Despite Mr. Giuliani's absence from the national stage, Tuesday
night's hobnobbing with Tom Wolfe, David Brooks and Mortimer Zuckerman
served as a reminder that the former Mayor is a genuine celebrity. He
enjoys enormous national name recognition and is widely seen as a
strong leader because of the resolve he showed during the Sept. 11
attacks.
But there is also a serious question of how long Mr. Giuliani can
remain at the top of national Republican polls (along with his friend,
Senator John McCain) while holding starkly unconservative positions on
abortion and gay rights. Moderation may work here in New York, but it
doesn't necessarily fly in the red states.
Perhaps for that reason, Mr. Giuliani has been skipping straw polls
and lying low to keep those issues—plus his two divorces—buried below
the headlines.
But some Republican strategists see in Mr. Giuliani's recent and
conspicuous support of conservative candidates an effort to quell
opposition from the Republican right wing should he eventually run.
"It gives him an opportunity to campaign for candidates and neutralize
the opposition," said Arnold Steinberg, a Republican strategist.
"Because there will be people who may not be for him, but they won't
be passionately against him."
And so Mr. Giuliani has dropped in on the Global Pastors of Florida,
campaigned with pro-life Senator Rick Santorum in Pennsylvania, and
signed on for a fund-raiser for Ralph Reed, the co-founder of the
Christian Coalition and a candidate for lieutenant governor in
Georgia. This weekend, he is holding a cocktail party for a more
like-minded Republican, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger of California.
The busy schedule also allows Mr. Giuliani to stay in the thick of
Presidential politics without overexposing himself in the national
limelight. By conquering new constituencies with tough talk about
national security, Mr. Giuliani is showing conservative America that
he is a candidate they can live with, if not love. And that could just
be enough if the Republican Party needs a New Yorker to stand up to
Mr. Giuliani's old foe, Senator Hillary Clinton, in a general
election.
And so Mr. Giuliani is dusting off some old Hillary barbs.
"We're both Yankee fans," Mr. Giuliani said of Mrs. Clinton while
campaigning this month with Senator Santorum in the home state of the
Philadelphia Phillies and the Pittsburgh Pirates. "I became a Yankee
fan growing up in New York. She became a Yankee fan growing up in
Chicago."
But Anthony V. Carbonetti, a top executive at Giuliani Partners, a
consulting firm, and a close advisor to Mr. Giuliani, warned that it
was too early to determine who would stand "at the other end of the
ring," meaning that it is unclear who will emerge as the Democratic
Party's nominee. He also emphasized that Mr. Giuliani hasn't decided
whether to run or not. He added, however, that if Mr. Giuliani does
run, he would find common ground with many in the Republican Party.
"If he decided to go forward, you get more into the record and the
accomplishments in New York," said Mr. Carbonetti, referring to the
historic decreases in crime and in welfare cases during Mr. Giuliani's
tenure as Mayor. "I would count on those accomplishments in any
Republican primary."
Still, to Republican candidates running in this year's midterm
election, Mr. Giuliani's appeal is based on Sept. 11. On April 6, Mr.
Giuliani reinforced that image with an appearance at the sentencing
trial of Zacarias Moussaoui, and the large majority of his nearly 150
talks in the last two years have addressed national security.
"He has been very active, but not on the typical dog-and-pony shows.
He doesn't do the straw polls in Memphis or the breakfast at the
Chamber of Commerce in New Hampshire," said Lee Miringoff, director of
the Marist Institute for Public Opinion. "Part of his mystique is that
he's out there as an unknown quantity. And I think he wants to keep
that as long as possible."
That said, Mr. Giuliani is increasing his visibility as the midterm
elections loom, and Mr. Carbonetti said he is "committed to
campaigning for and raising money for Republican candidates."
Republicans are desperately in need of someone who can help get voters
excited, and Mr. Giuliani can pack them in like few others.
Bound for Iowa
"It's an election year, and he is coming out here to help our
candidates, looking to get Republicans in Congress," said Sarah
Sauber, a spokeswoman for the Iowa Republican Party. On May 1, Mr.
Giuliani is scheduled to speak at a "Get Motivated" seminar in Iowa
that is expected to draw nearly 20,000 to the Wells Fargo Arena. He
will also make appearances at fund-raisers for Representative Jim
Nussle, a candidate for Governor, and Jeff Lamberti, a candidate for
Congress. The Iowa caucuses, of course, are the first important event
in the Presidential primary season.
A day after that, Mr. Giuliani goes to Washington, as the featured
guest at a fund-raiser for the National Republican Senatorial
Committee. According to the committee's spokesman, Brian Nick, Mr.
Giuliani is still a major draw and a "tremendous asset" for
Republicans. Mr. Nick said the former Mayor generates large amounts of
contributions that "will directly help candidates around the country."
Mr. Giuliani is also doing well for himself, thanks to lucrative
speaking engagements and the business of his Giuliani Partners
consulting firm. In 2005, he was named as a partner to the
Houston-based law firm Bracewell & Giuliani, which also helped build
connections in the South.
"He certainly has star power down here," said Jay W. Ragley, political
director of the Republican Party of South Carolina. Mr. Ragley said
that when the time came, voters would have to balance Mr. Giuliani's
less-than-conservative stance on social issues with his leadership
qualities, but added that in the meantime, "I think most Republican
people want to see him and be near him."
That sentiment was echoed around the country.
"When it comes to talking to folks about the importance of President
Bush's global war on terror," said Jeff Sadosky, a spokesman for the
Republican Party of Florida, "folks nationwide look to Rudy Giuliani."
As Mr. Giuliani builds a bank of favors to potentially cash in on
without suffering the scrutiny of an official Presidential bid, he
also has the luxury of keeping his options open. His flexibility can
prove maddening to political Sibyls.
"It's a popular parlor game in Washington, D.C., to handicap Rudy
Giuliani's potential path to a Presidential bid," said Nelson
Warfield, a Republican strategist who is dubious of Mr. Giuliani's
chances. "I think he has no shot in the South once people find out
about the Harvey Milk High School for gay teenagers [which was
expanded in 2001, during the Mayor's last year in office], and the
panoply of liberal and progressive issues that he has to explain."
Indeed, evangelist leader Jerry Falwell articulated such opposition
recently when he told CNN: "As conservative Christians who take the
Bible seriously, we have probably irreconcilable differences on life
and family and that kind of thing. I'll never speak an ill word about
[Mr. Giuliani], because he means so much to America. But I couldn't
support him for President."
Unless, perhaps, if Mr. Giuliani emerges as the lesser of two evils.
Mrs. Clinton, who already has raised more than $30 million for her
Senate re-election this year and is widely believed to be preparing
for a run for President, turns out to be Mr. Giuliani's best friend
when it comes to his own Presidential ambitions, according to many
Republican strategists. The prospect of a Hillary Presidency could
distract Southern conservatives from Mr. Giuliani's more liberal
social positions.
"They might fear her so much that they would embrace him," said Mr. Steinberg.
A combination of Mr. Giuliani's fame and Mrs. Clinton as an opponent
also gives him an edge when it comes to fund-raising.
"Seeing the success he has in raising money for other people, I'm
confident he would be successful," said Mr. Carbonetti, who said he
speaks regularly with Karl Rove, the President's deputy chief of staff
responsible for politics, and Ken Mehlman, the chairman of the
Republican National Committee. Political observers also think that a
Hillary candidacy opens up opportunities for Mr. Giuliani, even if he
doesn't make it through the primary. If a Republican candidate with
more traditionally conservative values on social issues ends up facing
Mrs. Clinton, there are few more attractive choices for Vice President
than Mr. Giuliani.
"Everybody looks for a base to run from," said Rick Wiley, executive
director of the Republican Party of Wisconsin. "Obviously, he would
really stymie her position to run up the score in New York. She would
have to look elsewhere to pick up those electoral votes."
Whatever the calculus turns out to be, Mr. Giuliani is causing plenty
of chin-scratching and anguish for politicians and analysts around the
country.
"He is an interesting candidate, because he is so strong in some areas
that conservatives are willing to overlook some of their differences
with him," said Republican pollster David Winston. "Making a decision
to run for President is not like any other. I think he is going
through a process of deciding what he is going to do."
With an ego that big, it's necessary to widen the roads....
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/local/story/412066p-348503c.html
Daily News 4/26/06
Road to Rudy will run Iowans $50G
Former Mayor Rudy Giuliani's planned trip to Iowa next week is already
costing taxpayers there $50,000 - for a special exit ramp to deal with
the planned crowds.
Giuliani, making his first foray into the presidential battleground
state since 2004, is due to speak at a "Get Motivated" seminar in Des
Moines on Monday, along with former boxing champ George Foreman,
personal finance guru Suze Orman and others.
But state officials are so worried that the expected 18,000 attendees
will jam area roads, they are paying a contractor an extra $50,000 to
widen a section of Interstate 235 and keep open an exit ramp that was
due to close for repairs.
"It is in the interest of public safety," said Bill Lusher, a project
manager for the Iowa Department of Transportation. "We are hoping that
as a result of this, we will have safe access to the [Giuliani] event
and hopefully avoid any accidents."
The former mayor, who is known to be weighing a bid for President in
2008, is also due to headline a state party fund-raiser in Des Moines
and, later, raise money for Republican Rep. Jim Nussle, who is running
for governor.
David Saltonstall
http://www.nysun.com/article/31581
Prince of the City
New York Sun Editorial
April 25, 2006
Mayor Giuliani will be honored tonight by the Manhattan Institute at
its annual Alexander Hamilton dinner, and it is hard to think of a
more fitting evening. It was the Manhattan Institute that nursed in
this town the ideas that triumphed in the 1990s - and are still
ascendant - and it was Mayor Giuliani who had the wisdom, the
foresight to go to the Manhattan Institute in search of ideas on which
to build a mayoralty that changed this city, that proved it could be
governable, and that laid the basis for the gains that have been made
by, in Mayor Bloomberg, another wonderful leader.
It has been more than four years since Mr. Giuliani left office, and
it is no small thing that there are still millions of New Yorkers, and
many millions of Americans, who are eager for more of his leadership.
The first time your editors sat down with him for an extended
conversation about political principles was in the early 1990s, when
he was running in the campaign that would, four years after a bitter
defeat, finally elevate him to the mayoralty. To this day we rank the
interview as one of the clearest, most coherent explications of a
political philosophy that we've ever heard.
This was when we first began to hear his talk of "one standard" and to
gain the sense that, behind all the tough-guy image and political
aggressiveness, was a serious intellectual in his own right, a person
who read and thought about issues. Certainly he could be
confrontational, toward, say, the professional poverty advocates and
race hustlers. But he could also be warm, toward the immigrants and
homeowners and small entrepreneurs that make this city great. And we
began to gain the sense then of one of his greatest traits, his
capacity for political incorrectness.
By this we mean the streak of his personality that could, say, send
police officers to escort Yasser Arafat out of a concert in the city
because he just understood that it was a mockery. This is the same
streak that permitted him to just tear up a $10 million check from a
Saudi billionaire when it came with language that was offensive to a
city in which 3,000 of its citizens had just been slaughtered in the
name of the same hatred the donor was preaching. This is a streak that
Mr. Giuliani shares with President Bush.
For the Manhattan Institute to honor Mr. Giuliani tonight makes a
statement about conservative ideals at a moment when the conservative
movement is at a crossroads. Some conservatives want to stop
supporting freedom abroad and attack immigration here at home. Mr.
Giuliani stands for an optimistic brand of conservatism that does not
tolerate terrorists or negotiate with them and that understands that
immigration strengthens America's culture and economy rather than
weakens it. In a conservative movement often hostile to government,
Mr. Giuliani understood the role of honest government and capitalism
in supporting freedom.
There's been a lot of talk about whether Mr. Giuliani will run for
president. There are plenty of good candidates, and this isn't the
moment for an endorsement. But count this newspaper as in the camp
that hopes Mr. Giuliani will run, not only because we think he'd do a
fine job of running the country were he to win but because his ideas -
on tax cuts, on fighting terrorism, on immigration, on vouchers for
private and parochial school students - would be healthy for the
national debate. We have not the slightest doubt that the audience
receptive to these kinds of ideas extends far beyond the crowd that
will gather tonight to see the prince of the city honored in the name
of Hamilton.
The youtube video plays awful for most. I sent it out to a few thousand people and asked for feedback and many people say it doesn.t even play for them.
<itsgiulianitime@...> wrote: > > hey friends, > > check out
www.giulianitime.com Get Involved page - we posted some > banners and the trailer. > > Also, the "Draft Rudy" campaign sent out an Action Alert on Monday > asking for money donation to combat "GIULIANI TIME" - there's a link > to the action alert posted on our website. > > We have sent the following release out: > > FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE > > April 17, 2006 > > > "Draft Rudy" Campaign Goes on the Attack Against "Giuliani Time" > Campaign Group Issues `Action Alert' Calling For Donations to Launch > A Campaign to Expose Inaccuracies in Film > > > LOS ANGELES – With a month to go before the release of "Giuliani > Time," Giuliani backers have put out an email Action Alert calling > for subscribers "to launch an effective campaign to expose the > inaccuracies in "Giuliani Time" and defend America's Mayor," > following the announcement of the documentary's theatrical release > plans last week. On Monday, Allen Fore, co-founder of the Draft Rudy > For President, NFP (
www.draftrudygiuliani.com) based in Chicago, > Illinois, called for campaign donation of "$20, $200, or $2,000...to > combat and expose this propaganda that is being disguised as a > documentary."
> > Plans for the film's theatrical release were announced last week. > National news outlets including the New York Times, New York Post and > MSNBC's "The Situation" with Tucker Carlson along with New York > regional media such as the Daily News, WCBS, NY1's "Inside City Hall" > and WABC covered the story extensively. Patrick Healy of the New > York Times called the film "Nothing less than a full frontal assault > on the civic deification of Rudolph W. Giuliani." David > Saltonstall's column in the New York Daily News opines that the > film "seeks to do for Giuliani what Michael Moore's `Farenheit 9/11' > did for President Bush." The New York Post took aim at the "leftie > flick." Director Kevin Keating was interviewed live on MSNBC's "The > Situation" with Tucker Carlson, on WCBS by Andrew Kirtzman, TV > journalist and author of "Emperor of the City," one of the first > books on Giuliani's term as mayor, and on "Inside City Hall" by > Dominic Carter, who covered City Hall during Giuliani's reign.
> > In the Action Alert, the "Draft Rudy" organization claims the > film "tries to distort reality and ruin the reputation of an American > hero." Keating's film analyzes Giuliani's family history, his > disastrous record on the First Amendment, the use and abuse of > government powers and the severe methods he employed to enforce the > Quality of Life and Zero Tolerance campaigns in New York City. In > making the film, director Kevin Keating researched the film for four > years, shot approximately 300 hours of footage and culled through > another 200 hours of network and archival footage. The filmmakers > interviewed key people who worked with Giuliani's administration as > well as long-time Giuliani advocates from the Manhattan Institute > (Myron Magnet and Heather McDonald), George Kelling and Fred > Siegel. The film features interviews with former New York City > Police Commissioner William S. Bratton, former New York City School > Commissioner Rudy Grew, and Wayne Barrett, the Village Voice's Senior > Editor who has written extensively on Giuliani ("Rudy!: An > Investigative Biography of Rudolph Giuliani"). "The movie does track > sections from my book," says Barrett. "When the book came out in > 2000, it was covered extensively by the media and Giuliani was > challenged directly about what the book revealed. None of the facts > presented in the book were questioned by Giuliani."
> > The film will open in New York at the Landmark's Sunshine Cinema on > May 12 and widen to select theaters across the country. Cinema Libre > Studio has worldwide rights. For more information about the film > visit www.giulianitime.com. > > > FOR MORE INFORMATION: > >
> Draft Rudy Campaign - http://www.draftrudygiuliani.com/ > > > · From Wikipedia: "Draft Rudy Giuliani for President, Inc., > [23] registered with Federal Election Commission in October 2005 to > become the first federal committee formed with the sole purpose of > encouraging former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani to run for President > of the United States in 2008. As of January 2006, it remains the only > committee formed for this reason. By law, Draft Rudy Giuliani for > President cannot coordinate its activities with the former mayor." > > > > · Action Alert posted at: www.giulianitime.com > > > > ABOUT CINEMA LIBRE STUDIO: > > Cinema Libre Studio is a haven for independent filmmakers with views, > offering one-stop shopping for production, co-production, > distribution, foreign sales, marketing, and post-production services. > Headquartered in Los Angeles, the company is best known for > distributing in theaters and on DVD titles that > include "Outfoxed," "Uncovered," Tim Robbins' "Embedded > Live," "Giuliani Time" and "Through the Fire." Several Cinema Libre > Studio productions currently in festivals have recently won awards > including "Conventioneers,"(Winner of the 2006 Independent Spirit > Awards `John Cassavetes' Award (best feature under $500,000) and Best > Feature at the Miami International Film Festival), "The Empire in > Africa," won Best Documentary at Slamdance 2006, and "Giuliani Time" > won Best Documentary art the SilverLake Film Festical. For more > information visit
www.cinemalibrestudio.com. > > > EDITORS AND PRODUCERS: > > If you are interested in receiving a screener or to schedule an > interview with director Kevin Keating, please contact Mary Keeler at
> mkeeler@... or call 818-349-8822.
> > > To download images and other information, please visit >
www.giulianitime.com. > > > - 30 - >
Between the lines....
Here's an article from today's issue of Crains about wealthy donors to
the arts. It's a puff piece on how wonderful the wealthy art donors
are. What the article doesn't mention is how many of the people named
are associated with the CIA – and with worse things.
While admiring their generosity you might consider where their money
came from. The invisible common thread throughout the Crains article
is Rockefeller-CIA-EXXON-Nazi. Check it out....
For example, MOMA, according to The Cultural Cold War by Francis
Stoner Saunders, has been a CIA front ever since the CIA was created
after WWII. Most of its early directors were themselves CIA officials.
MOMA is the Rockefeller family museum, yet it gets tax funds from the
City of NY. MOMA has repeatedly been sued for possessing art stolen
from Jews by the Nazis during the Holocaust. Roger Hertog, the
philanthropist repeatedly mentioned below, is the Chairman of the
Board of the Manhattan Institute (MI). MI is the think tank behind all
of Bush and Giuliani's most controversial policy ideas. Hertog also
runs Alliance Capital Management, which financed ENRON. MI was founded
by Reagan's CIA director, William Casey. Giuliani was the #3 man in
Reagan's Justice Dept and worked closely with Casey. Casey helped
bring thousands of former Nazi officials to the US after the war, many
of who were employed by the then new CIA. MI was financed by Chase
Bank, the Rockefeller family bank that helped finance Adolf Hitler.
Standard Oil, now known as EXXON, is the Rockfeller oil company that
is now the world's largest corporation, you know, the one ripping us
all off at the gas pump. Standard Oil was half owner of IG Farben, the
German pharmaceutical/chemical/munitions company that built and ran
Auschwitz and 40 other Nazi slave labor camps. Think I'm making this
stuff up? See the mainstream quotes at the end of the Crains article.
That's who's sponsoring NY's art.
CRAINS
April 24, 2006
Arts contributors may get big return
by Steve Garmhausen
Agnes Gund has spent much of the past five decades buying modern art
by the likes of Jasper Johns and Mark Rothko. But she has also given
scores of works away to the Museum of Modern Art.
"It could be because I feel guilty about having so much more than most
people," says MoMA's president emerita, who has contributed some 250
pieces to the museum. "If I can have it, others should be able to
enjoy it."
Ms. Gund, heiress to a Cleveland banking fortune, is the embodiment of
the New York City arts patron. Wealthy New Yorkers love to support
culture: As a group, the arts are the second-biggest recipient of
donations from local foundations, after educational charities, says
Kathleen McCarthy, director of the Center on Philanthropy and Civil
Society at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York. The
arts trail education and health in most areas of the country.
Richard Marker, a philanthropy expert with Marker Goldsmith Advisors,
says, "People who give to the arts see it as supporting a national
treasure."
Such benefactors have a variety of motivations in deciding which
institutions they'll support. Altruism is one, but so is the desire
for prestige. Then there's the issue of who requests the help, says
Naomi Levine, who brought in more than $2 billion over 22 years as New
York University's chief fund-raiser.
"It depends very much on the priorities in your life, and it also
depends on who asks and gets you involved," Ms. Levine says.
For Ms. Gund, it was two friends who asked back in 1967. Though she
was just in her 20s and still in her native Ohio, Ms. Gund was already
a collector. The friends talked her into joining MoMA's international
council, which raises money for shows outside New York. After moving
here, Ms. Gund held a number of positions at the museum, including
president.
Choosing carefully
Ronald Ulrich, the chairman of Equinox Capital Management, is engaged
as a New York Philharmonic "Maestro" contributor--someone who has
committed $100,000 over three years.
"I've tended to be pretty closely involved when I've been a
significant donor," says Mr. Ulrich, who sits on the orchestra's
executive committee and heads the development panel. He sometimes
attends three or more meetings a week.
Others are less hands-on. Roger Hertog, vice chairman of investment
firm Alliance Bernstein, is on the board of the New-York Historical
Society and is a trustee of the New York Public Library, two of the
biggest recipients of the "many millions" that he and his wife, Susan,
give annually. "Many times just being an investor is good enough," Mr.
Hertog says. "You can't be involved in that many things and really
make a serious contribution."
Choosing among New York's cultural groups isn't easy, he says. The
ones he picks have strong leadership, a defined vision and a solid
plan to achieve their goals. Often, they match his personal interests.
Mr. Hertog is an American history buff, which helps explain his
support for the society. And he and his wife, both of whom grew up in
the Bronx, credit library branches with augmenting their public school
educations. The couple has more than returned the favor: They are the
main private donors behind the NYPL's $50 million Bronx Library
Center, which opened in January.
Whether donors accept public recognition varies. Some will, but only
for the good of the institution, says Francie Ostrower, senior
researcher at the Urban Institute and author of Why the Wealthy Give
and Trustees of Culture: Power, Wealth, and Status on Elite Arts
Boards.
"Some people will have their name associated because the organization
convinces them that it helps get other donors," Ms. Ostrower says.
"Other people need no convincing."
Several buildings at Mr. Ulrich's alma mater, Lehigh University, bear
his name, but he says he could take or leave the honor. Ms. Gund says
she, too, can do without the plaudits. MoMA's Agnes Gund Garden Lobby,
overlooking the Abby Aldrich Rockefeller Sculpture Garden, was so
named at David Rockefeller's insistence, she explains.
And the Agnes Gund Artist's Choice Exhibition Fund, which allows
artists to curate shows from MoMA's collection, was endowed by her
four brothers to honor her service to the museum.
Nothing is named after Mr. Hertog, and he likes it that way. "I know
my own name," he says. "I'm interested in the vision, the leadership,
the plan, the ideas."
10.9% is the percentage of disposable income that city residents gave
away in 2003. According to a study of U.S. urban areas by the
Chronicle of Philanthropy, that level tied them with Fort Worth-area
residents as No. 2 in munificence, behind Detroiters, who donated
12.1%.
Philanthropists like Roger Hertog and Ronald Ulrich are not as
recognizable as high-profile names like David Rockefeller. Mr.
Rockefeller, the chairman emeritus of MoMA, announced last year that
his will would include a $100 million bequest to the institution. He
also plans to give the museum $5 million annually until his death.
Comments? cnyb@...
(c)2006 Crain Communications Inc.
NY Times Monday, May 12, 1997 Manhattan Institute Has
Nudged New York Rightward
"...the institute was founded as a free-market education and
research organization by William Casey, who then went off to
head the Central Intelligence Agency in the Reagan
Administration."
NY Times June 12, 2000 Bush Culls Campaign Theme
From Conservative Thinkers
"Gov. George W. Bush has said his political views have been
shaped by the work of Myron Magnet of the Manhattan
Institute."
Daily News 12/7/98 Chase Banked On Nazis - Report
"The New York-based bank controlled by the Rockefeller
family closed Jewish accounts even before the Germans
ordered them to do so and did business with the Nazis while
they were sending Jews to the gas chambers, Newsweek
magazine reports in this week's edition. And while the U.S.
was at war with the Nazis, Chase also apparently helped
German banks do business with their overseas branches, the
magazine reported...The relationship between Chase and the
Nazis apparently was so cozy that Carlos Niedermann, the
Chase branch chief in Paris, wrote his supervisor in Manhattan
that the bank enjoyed "very special esteem" with top German
officials and "a rapid expansion of deposits." Niedermann's
letter was written in May 1942 -- five months after the
Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor and the U.S. also went to war
with Germany...And subsidiaries of Ford and General Motors
have been accused of forcing thousands of Jews, Poles and
others to work as slave laborers."
"The Bush family fortune came from the Third
Reich,"-Sarasota Herald-Tribune 11/11/2000 -Former US
Justice Dept. Nazi War Crimes prosecutor John Loftus-who is
today the director of the Florida Holocaust Museum.
FROM:
The CIA and the Cultural Cold War by Frances Stonor Saunders,
"The CIA and its allies in the Museum of Modern Art (MOMA) poured vast
sums of money into promoting Abstract Expressionist (AE) painting and
painters as an antidote to art with a social content. In promoting AE,
the CIA fought off the right-wing in Congress. What the CIA saw in AE
was an "anti-Communist ideology, the ideology of freedom, of free
enterprise. Non-figurative and politically silent it was the very
antithesis of socialist realism" (254). They viewed AE as the true
expression of the national will. To bypass right-wing criticism, the
CIA turned to the private sector (namely MOMA and its co-founder,
Nelson Rockefeller, who referred to AE as "free enterprise painting.")
Many directors at MOMA had longstanding links to the CIA and were more
than willing to lend a hand in promoting AE as a weapon in the
cultural Cold War. Heavily funded exhibits of AE were organized all
over Europe; art critics were mobilized, and art magazines churned out
articles full of lavish praise. The combined economic resources of
MOMA and the CIA-run Fairfield Foundation ensured the collaboration of
Europe's most prestigious galleries which, in turn, were able to
influence aesthetics across Europe."
"Moma has even been outed as a front for the CIA in the 50s, when its
international touring shows of American art were supposedly little
more than Cold War propaganda exercises."
UK Guardianunlimited 8/29/2000
"Mayor Rudolph W. Guiliani pledged Thursday that the city would
contribute $65 million over the next three years to help pay for a
major expansion project at the Museum of Modern Art...Facing its huge
price tag, trustees from the museum's expansion committee, including
David Rockefeller, the real estate developer Jerry Speyer and Donald
Marron, the chairman of PaineWebber Inc., approached City Hall. Mr.
Rockefeller, whose mother, Abby Aldrich Rockefeller, was a founder of
the Modern, said the city money was "the financial cornerstone" of the
expansion. Of the remaining $585 million the museum must raise, he
said that about $200 million had been pledged by "the family and
trustees." Then he quickly added a qualifier: "When I say family, I
mean the museum family, not my family."
NY TIMES 4/24/98 MOMA to Get $65 Million for Expansion
"During the war, Rockefeller foreshadowed the anticommunist policies
of the Cold War by cozying up to dictatorial regimes in Latin America.
Niccola Tucci, head of the State Departmentís Bureau of Latin American
Research, resigned and asked Secretary of State Cordell Hull to
abolish his bureau. "My bureau was supposed to undo the Nazi and
fascist propaganda in South America and Rockefeller was inviting the
worst fascists and Nazis to Washington." Tucci took his objections to
Rockefeller and was told: "Everybody is useful and weíre going to
convert these people to friendliness to the United States.mAnd then,
Rockefellerís lawyer Larry Levy said to me, "Don't worry, we'll buy
those people." (Peter Collier and David Horowitz, The Rockefellers: An
American Dynasty. Holt, Rine-hart & Winston, 1976, p. 236).
From The Cultural Cold War by Frances Stonor Saunders, New Press [pg 132]
"The fund raising arm of the Free Europe Committee [a CIA front] was
The Crusade for Freedom for which a young actor named Ronald Reagan
was a leading spokeman and publicist. The Crusade for Freedom was used
to launder money to support a programme run by Bill Casey, the future
CIA director, called the International Refugee Committee in New York
[aka International Rescue Committee], which allegedly coordinated the
exfiltration of Nazis from Germany to the United States where they
were expected to assist the government in fighting Communism...[pg
142]...The Ford Foundation gave $500,000 to Bill Caseyís International
Rescue Committee and substantial grants to another CIA front, the
World Assembly of Youth...the convergence between the Rockefeller
billions and the U.S. government exceeded even that of the Ford
Foundation ."
Daily News 12/24/98
Chase Named In Holocaust-Asset Suit
"Two American banks were named in a class-action lawsuit yesterday
that accuses them of collaborating with the Nazis to deprive Jewish
depositors of their rightful assets. "They froze and blocked Jewish
accounts during the period of the Nazi occupation in France, depriving
Jewish families of the financial means to flee France," said attorney
Kenneth McCallion, who filed the suit against Chase Manhattan Bank,
J.P. Morgan and seven French banks. ...McCallion charges Chase's Paris
branch ó with full backing of its New York office ó displayed
"excessive zeal" in enforcing anti-Jewish laws and was held in "very
special esteem" by Vichy authorities. Court papers also say Chase
prospered under German occupation, nearly doubling its deposits
between 1942 and 1944 from 27 million to more than 50 million French
francs...Chase officials said in a statement that it has been in
settlement talks with the World Jewish Congress for several weeks and
that it was disappointed that an "unnecessary" lawsuit has been
filed."
"Chase Manhattan Corp. apologized yesterday for aiding Adolf Hitler's
Third Reich by converting German marks into U.S. dollars between 1936
and 1941. Because many countries refused to accept German currency
during the war, the Nazis used foreign banks like Chase National to
change the currency into money that would be accepted. "We are sad to
learn and deeply troubled about the involvement of one of our
predecessor banks in a program that benefited Germany during that
period," said William Harrison Jr., chief executive officer of Chase.
"We have a responsibility to make this information public and wish to
express our sincere apologies to the Jewish community and to the
American public." Chase does not, however, intend to make financial
reparations for the role it played in aiding Hitler and the Nazis."
-Daily News 2/23/2000 CHASE APOLOGIZES FOR DOING BIZ WITH NAZIS
From: The Secret War Against the Jews pg. 168
"In 1936 the Rockefellers entered into partnership with Dulles's Nazi
front, the Schroder Bank of New York, which, as we have already seen,
was the key institution of the Fascist economic miracle. In 1939 the
Rockefeller-controlled Chase National Bank secured $25 million for
Nazi Germany and supplied Berlin with information on ten thousand Nazi
sympathizers in the United States. Except for a few months
interruption the Rockefeller-owned Standard Oil of New Jersey shipped
oil to the Nazis through Spain all throughout the war. The roster of
the Rockefellers known pro-Nazi behavior is horrendous. As previously
outlined, in 1942 Senator Harry Truman described the behavior of the
Rockefeller company as treasonous...On September 22, 1947, Federal
Judge Charles Clark issued the following opinion in a civil case:
"Standard Oil can be considered an enemy national in view of its
relationship with I.G. Farben after the U.S. and Germany had become
active enemies".
NOTE: My forwarding this or any other article does not mean I
necessarily endorse the viewpoint expressed therein. If the view
expressed below is true, it would explain many things about 9/11
including Giuliani's part in it.
Keep in mind, #7 was unquestionably brought down by explosives, or
pulled, to quote the owner and the FDNY. It housed the local
headquarters of the CIA, FBI and other Federal agencies. From the day
Giuliani first proposed putting his bunker there the question was, why
locate NYC's emergency command center in the building Federal
authorites most expected to be attacked by terrorists?
FWD:
http://www.prisonplanet.com/articles/april2006/210406runattack.htm
Former German Minister Says Building 7 Used To Run 9/11 Attack
Guide the planes in, then destroy the crime scene
Paul Joseph Watson & Alex Jones/Prison Planet.com | April 21 2006
Former Helmut Schmidt cabinet member, 25-year German Parliamentarian
and global intelligence expert Andreas Von Bülow says that the 9/11
attack was run by the highest levels of the US intelligence apparatus
using WTC Building 7 as a command bunker which was later demolished in
order to destroy the crime scene.
Speaking to The Alex Jones Show on the GCN Radio Network, Von Bülow
said that "the official story is so wrong, it must be an inside job."
Von Bülow discussed the special software programs that allow the CIA
to track suspicious stock market movements in real time. Record put
options placed on United and American Airlines in the week before
9/11, a speculation that the stock would crash, clearly indicated
inside foreknowledge of the impending attack.
"If the stock market has very strange movements immediately they take
care of this and they had a lot of tapes and the lawyers told the
people destroy these tapes."
"The Bush administration is in a deep defensive [mode] and probably
they would like to come out with a new offensive," said Von Bülow as
he considered whether a new staged false flag terror attack could be
launched to further an interventionist agenda.
"I would hope that one 'new Pearl Harbor' is enough," said Von Bülow,
"but I cannot be sure."
Von Bülow commented on the disputed identities of the named hijackers.
"The names of these nineteen [hijackers] never came up in the official
passenger list, until now there's no proof they were on the planes."
Von Bülow also pointed out how the alleged hijacker's flight
instructors told investigators that they couldn't even fly Cessna's,
never mind complex large commercial airliners.
Von Bülow also touched upon the implausible collapse of the buildings.
"The towers came down in the velocity of free fall which is totally
impossible, they fall down in 8, 9, or 10 seconds, the pancake theory
is ridiculous," he said.
Von Bülow also highlighted the fact that there were 67 successful
intercepts of errant aircraft in the year of 2001 before 9/11 and yet
four planes were allowed to veer wildly off course without any being
intercepted on that one day.
Rudolph Giuliani opened a $13 million emergency Command Center
(pictured) on the 23rd floor of World Trade Center Building 7 in June
1999 in part to respond to and manage terrorist attacks.
Von Bülow referenced the command bunker in Building 7, calling it the
"optimal place" to run the attacks using remote control technology to
guide the planes in and then destroying the crime scene by imploding
the building.
"There were two procedures, one was flying in the aircraft the second
was the explosions," he said.
When asked precisely which parties carried out the attack Von Bülow
said it must have been a "very small group" within the CIA with the
help of Saudi Arabian and Pakistani secret service intelligence.
Von Bülow outlined his view that one reason for the execution of 9/11
was to provide the justification for US military bases in the near and
Middle East to be built in anticipation for a future confrontation
with China, whom the Neo-Cons believe have grown too powerful and need
to have their geopolitical wings clipped.
Click here to listen to Von Bülow's interview.
--------------------------end-----------------
WEBSITE FOR THE FILM GIULIANITIME
http://www.giulianitime.com/
Yahoo group for the film with many background documents on Giuliani,
previews and reviews of the film
http://movies.groups.yahoo.com/group/itsgiulianitime/
Also see these sites for thousands of articles, essays, photos, court
rulings etc. on Giuliani
http://bluecollarpolitics.com/lederman/http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Arrest-Giuliani/http://groups.yahoo.com/group
Man Who Would be King: Director Kevin Keating Talks About Giuliani
Time
http://www.politicalaffairs.net/article/articleview/3257/1/162/
By Political Affairs
Editor's Note: Kevin Keating is director and co-producer of the
recently released Giuliani Time.
PA: When did you first think about doing this film?
KK: I didn't have the original idea. I was approached by a friend
and colleague in 1998, Michael Ratner, president of the Center for
Constitutional Rights. Ratner was alarmed at the situation with
Giuliani, and had a general idea for a film that examined Giuliani's
rapidly accumulating record of violations of individual and group
First Amendment rights. From the repeated New York police refusal of
permits for demonstrations, to the sweeping arrests of street
artists, Guiliani's legal position as chief executive (and the
lawyers at the corporation counsel defense of these policies), was a
radical departure from previous administrations.
We agreed to begin the research and commence shooting with a very
limited budget for a film to be completed within six months. It
quickly became obvious that First Amendment issues were too narrow a
focus. New policing practices then known as "quality of life"
policing became prominent and could not be excluded.
One of the first interviews we filmed was with William Bratton, the
first police commissioner under Giuliani. He had also headed the
then separate transit police under Mayor Dinkins, with great
success. Bratton had implemented the initial police "quality of
life" strategies predicated on a neoconservative theory of policing
known as "broken windows." He resigned after receiving too much
credit for the shift from screaming headlines about crime, to
adulation for a sharp drop in crime that had actually begun three
years before under David Dinkins. That interview took place in 1999,
three days after the police killing of Amadou Diallo. Events of
enormous importance occurred with a strange regularity almost weekly
from then on: the "Sensation" exhibit at the Brooklyn Museum (and
Giuliani's bizarre attempt to have the museum evicted), the
draconian implementation of "workfare," and the destruction of the
World Trade Center and Giuliani's elevation to a kind of secular
sainthood in 2001.
Eventually, it would take over five years to shoot over 300 hours of
film, and screen and edit hundreds of hours of network and archival
footage driven by the variety and complexity of the issues. In
addition the publication of Wayne Barrett's invaluable investigative
biography, Rudy, provided an enormous amount of data along with the
revelations of Giuliani's family criminal history and the startling
possibility that he may well have deceived the FBI in the original
backround check when first interviewed for work in the criminal
division of the Justice Department. A long difficult journey from
the limited scope of the original idea.
PA: Why did you select a film on Rudy Guiliani and not Ed Koch, a
very controversial mayor; or David Dinkins, the first African
American mayor in NYC?
KK: While both Ed Koch and David Dinkins are interesting subjects,
and both are in our film, we were surrounded by a barrage of
controversies that Giuliani generated from the moment he was
elected. One of the components of the film that will be of
historical value is that we were present and filming events as they
unfolded.
We were able to capture footage so that we could bringing a
deeper "social change" documentarian predisposition and emphasis to
the approach of the subjects we were rendering on film, for
instance, the demonstrations responding to the police killing of
Amadou Diallo. Relying on network news footage, particularly at the
local level is extremely constricting, as that material is loaded
with the ideological biases of the corporate media, and largely
limited only to material that was broadcast at the time.
So it was not a matter of choosing among recent mayors, but rather
focusing on Giuliani's dramatic multi faceted controversies and
choosing among them.
PA: You seemed to draw parallels between Giuliani and Ronald Reagan
and George Bush, yet the mayor has a reputation as being for
abortion and other issues which are not part of the Republican
president's agenda.
KK: Giuliani pronounces the battle between the great ideas of our
epoch as those between Roosevelt and Reagan. He chooses to be an
instrument for destroying the advances of the New Deal. Unlike other
leading lights of the right wing of the Republican party, he is a
product of an urban environment. The era of a kind of social
democratic, working-class-oriented national and local government
that was at its apex in New York City when Giuliani was born to a
workingclass family in Brooklyn in 1944. There were Communists like
Vito Marcantonio on the City Council. LaGuardia as mayor had a
friend in Roosevelt, and participated actively in implementing the
New Deal, from the WPA programs to free health care provided by the
city. Giuliani was a product of that progressive era, and describes
being an enthusiastic Democrat from high school through Manhattan
College where he had a column in the newspaper titled Ars Politica,
regularly attacking conservative Barry Goldwater and supporting
Kennedy. He claims he was ardently against the war on Vietnam, and
even voted for Democrat George McGovern in 1972. It wasn't until
1980 that he registered as a Republican just before going to work in
the Reagan administration. He had been in the criminal division of
the Justice Department for years earlier beginning during the Nixon
administration, and very ambitious, associating with powerful
Republicans like Judge Harold Tyler, who took him under his wing
very early on, and no doubt schooled him in the ways of going along
to get along in Washington. The ideological transformation may not
have been as complete. That is to say, even now, after essentially
welding himself to a proudly fundamentalist Christian, George Bush,
he still claims to be "pro-choice" and not anti gay. He oversaw the
implementation of the changes to civil service protections of health
benefits for same-sex couples who are city workers for instance. I
have no doubt that should he have to choose between attachments to
those liberal principals and his life-long ambition to becoming
president, we will witness a repeat of his bizarre attempt to evict
the Brooklyn Museum.
PA: You point out the contradictions between Giuliani's father's
crime connections and his seemingly lying about knowing about them.
Why didn't the press pursue this?
KK: With the publication of Wayne Barrett's incredible book his
amazing discoveries about the criminal histories of Giuliani's
father Harold Giuliani, his uncle and a cousin who was killed by the
FBI, the tabloid press, even incredibly, the Giuliani organ the New
York Post, did briefly trumpet headlines like "HIS MOB KIN." By that
time he had pulled out of the race for the Senate, ostensibly
because of his recently diagnosed prostate cancer. The public was
exhausted with Giuliani and he was nothing more than a lame duck,
and a rather deflated one at that. The follow-up by the press was
weak, with little interest, of course, until the events of September
11, 2001, and his ascension to super hero status as the press in
unison genuflected before his "bravery and leadership."
PA: How does the Manhattan Institute tie in with the mayor? What are
its corporate ties?
KK: The Manhattan Institute is an influential conservative
foundation formed by William Casey, Reagan's director of the CIA in
the late 1950's. It has connections to the Pioneer Fund, a shadowy,
extremist right-wing funding source, that publishes racist,
eugenicist propaganda similar to the John Birch Society.
With lavish financial support from the usual reactionary sources
like the Mellon-Scaife, Bradley and other corporate foundations,
they publish books like The Bell Curve, and Fixing Broken Windows. A
lavishly produced periodical City Journal is the venue for many neo
conservative authors writing about urban policies from policing to
ending welfare. We had the pleasure of interviewing a number of them
for the film, including Myron Magnet the publisher, and I think they
contribute some colorful and controversial notions of governing from
their proudly declared support of a "tycoonism" led state to the
observation that "hunger is not a problem in our country, obesity
is." Giuliani was schooled at Manhattan Institute after his defeat
by Dinkins, and proudly implemented many of the ideas promulgated by
the Manhattan Institute and continues to declare how important his
exposure to their writers and publications are to his political
positions.
PA: In your film the police union seems to have taken a 180 degree
turn from support to opposition.
KK: After convincing themselves it was the NYPD rank and file who
deserved most of the credit for the widely reported drop in crime,
at the end of Giuliani's term they still didn't have a contract. He
pulled the same anti union tactics he did with the teachers' union
and with others. If they didn't allow themselves to be bought, like
AFSME's DC-37 under Hill, they were dismissed out of hand. The
lubrication provided by enormous increases in overtime covered with
the rubric of "quality of life policing" finally overcame them and
they were face to face with the most anti labor mayor in recent
history.
PA: Former school chancellor Rudy Crew along with Bratton seem to
come out against him. Why hasn't this changed the mythology?
KK: What comes to mind when you hear the name Teddy Roosevelt? The
most chauvinist, militarist and imperialist president since Polk
invaded Mexico, and somehow one doesn't recollect the names of the
luminaries like Mark Twain who were active in the Anti-Imperialist
Society, that was broadly popular with the American people of the
late 1900's. While in the film Bratton soundly condemns Giuliani
for "breaking the back of the NYPD," and retarding the suppression
of crime strategies he felt would be successful, or being "tone-deaf
when it comes to issues of race," everyone has moved on. I think the
same is true of Chancellor Crew, who was forced out after refusing
to go along with the mayor's efforts to privatize schools with a
voucher plan. His comments about Giuliani's essential "pathology"
when it comes to issues of race I think are some of the most
powerful, and important ideas expressed in the film.
It will take some enormous negative revelations of information,
facts regarding Giuliani's actual leadership for the conventional
wisdom to be altered about his "heroic" role that day.
Giuliani's consulting firm specializes in helping some of America's
biggest corporate crooks beat prosecution. Here's a chance for
reporters to question him............
http://releases.usnewswire.com/GetRelease.asp?id=64432
Rudy Giuliani to Address D.C.-Area Legal Community at WMACCA Event on
Corporate Compliance on April 25
4/24/2006 12:45:00 PM
To: Assignment Desk, Daybook Editor
Contact: Ilene G. Reid of WMACCA, 301-230-1864, WMACCA@...; or
Danni Sabota of Bracewell & Giuliani, 713-221-1279,
danni.sabota@...
News Advisory:
Tuesday, April 25, Noon to 2 p.m. Luncheon Program
12:45 p.m. Giuliani Keynote
1:15 p.m. Panel of Legal Experts
The Ritz-Carlton Tysons Corner, 1700 Tysons Blvd., McLean, Va.
Former New York Mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani will address the Washington,
D.C.-area legal community for the first time at a corporate counsel
event hosted by the Washington Metropolitan Area Corporate Counsel
Association (WMACCA), April 25.
Giuliani, name partner at Bracewell & Giuliani LLP, will share his
views on the effect that recent prosecutorial and regulatory actions
are having on corporate officers and board directors.
Following Giuliani's keynote remarks, a panel of in-house corporate
counsel and lawyers from Bracewell & Giuliani will discuss how
corporate counsel can identify and resolve problems to reduce their
company's risk of government investigation and the evolving role of
corporate and criminal counsel in internal investigations. Panelists
will also discuss how to recognize and interpret warning signs that a
specific industry is becoming a priority for scrutiny and how to
decide when to fight or to acquiesce if a company is under government
investigation.
NOTE: All reporters planning to attend must reserve a spot with Ilene
Reid at 301-523-6846 (cell) or 301-230-1864 (office). Reporters
wishing to cover Giuliani's remarks should arrive no later than 12:15
p.m. for set up.
http://www.usnewswire.com/
-0-
/(c) 2006 U.S. Newswire 202-347-2770/
-------- Original Message --------
Subject: [911InsideJobbers] Re: Why isn't this man (Giuliani) the
target of activists in NYC?
Date: Sun, 23 Apr 2006 17:53:39 -0000
From: Lynn Ertell <lynnertell@...>
Reply-To: 911InsideJobbers@yahoogroups.com
To: 911InsideJobbers@yahoogroups.com
My thoughts exactly.
How is it possible for New Yorkers to be so compliant and supine ...
while knowing that they have been used as bloody props in the hoax of
the century ?
How degraded and impotent they must feel ...
Especially the huge numbers of prostituted firemen, cops and city
workers who know the truth about what happened on 9/11 ....
If they even pause for a moment in thought, in self-conscious
reflection of their situation, having to acknowledge such submission
to corrupt authority, and pure humiliation ...
plus the large numbers of sick and dying from the longer-term effects
of the demolitions ....
Imagine how those New Yorkers must be rationalizing their continuing
tolerance of him; let alone the public and media rituals of adoration
over his "heroism"; Giuliani now fabulously wealthy, fattened by an
endless gravy train of "Homeland Security" consulting contracts.
And all those New Yorkers had to do was let themselves be USED as
passive props in a giant staged pyro-technic display, complete with
exploding skyscrapers and falling bodies.
Not REAL PEOPLE (with the real emotional affect of outraged victims),
but rather, mute objects - moving props and stage "extras" ...
shuffling off to the rest of their enslaved lives.
--- In 911InsideJobbers@yahoogroups.com, "Greg Nixon" <nxngrg@...> wrote:
>
> In a city of how many million...he should NEVER be able to leave his
> office or speak without being callled out as a monster and mass
> murderer. What is NYC doing? I see NY911truth.org picked up on the
> Spitzer angle, why not Giuliani?
>
>
> Giuliani urges calm in times of chaos
> By HANK DANISZEWSKI, FREE PRESS REPORTER
> http://lfpress.ca/newsstand/News/Local/2006/04/22/pf-1545235.html
>
> As mayor of the city he proudly calls "the capital of the world,"
> Rudy Giuliani thought he had prepared for every kind of disaster.
> But he told a London audience last night that on Sept 11, 2001, he
> hadn't counted on terrorists using planes as missiles to destroy the
> World Trade Center in New York.
> But Giuliani said he remembered the advice his father gave him if he
> ever was trapped in a fire.
> "Become the calmest person in the room, or pretend that you are, and
> you will find the way out," he said.
> Giuliani's confident and decisive manner made him a beacon of hope
> in the hysteria that followed the terrorist attacks.
> He's now being touted as a possible Republican presidential
> candidate.
> Giuliani was the featured speaker at a day-long conference on crisis
> leadership organized by students of the Richard Ivey School of
> Business at the University of Western Ontario.
> Introduced by former London and Toronto police chief Julian Fantino,
> now Ontario's emergency commissioner, Giuliani gave an animated
> speech to about 1,100 people at the London Convention Centre,
> outlining the qualities of great leadership as he strode back and
> forth across the stage.
> He said Winston Churchill and Ronald Reagan were examples of great
> leaders who were guided by their principles, not public opinion
> polls.
> "You find out what people want and then you say it to them. It feels
> good, but it isn't leadership."
> Giuliani recalled going to Ground Zero on Sept. 11 and watching in
> horror as victims jumped out of the burning towers to their death.
> Though the disaster could not have been imagined, he said the city
> had plans for other disasters which could quickly be adapted.
> "If you prepare for everything you can anticipate, you will be
> prepared for the unanticipated because it will just be a variation,"
> he said.
> Born to a working-class family in Brooklyn, Giuliani became a lawyer
> and gained a reputation as a tough prosecutor.
> In 1993, he was elected mayor of New York and was credited for
> turning the city around, with a steep drop in crime and welfare
> rates.
> In a news conference, Giuliani said London is on the right track in
> tackling smaller problems such as graffiti and vandalism.
> Giuliani said even though New York had more than 2,000 murders a
> year when he became mayor, he also went after smaller problems such
> as vandalism and graffiti because it degraded neighbourhoods. He
> said graffiti offenders often were sentenced to clean up the mess.
> "You have to attack the big problems, but you cannot ignore the
> small -- one has a relationship to the other."
> Giuliani told the audience terrorism attacks will always pose a
> risk, but Americans and Canadians must prepare and not be ruled by
> fear.
> "You have to take risks to live."
>
Yahoo! Groups Links
The youtube video plays awful for most. I sent it out to a few
thousand people and asked for feedback and many people say it doesn.t
even play for them.
You might want to use google video
Charlie
www.playahata.com
--- In itsgiulianitime@yahoogroups.com, "itsgiulianitime"
<itsgiulianitime@...> wrote:
>
> hey friends,
>
> check out www.giulianitime.com Get Involved page - we posted some
> banners and the trailer.
>
> Also, the "Draft Rudy" campaign sent out an Action Alert on Monday
> asking for money donation to combat "GIULIANI TIME" - there's a
link
> to the action alert posted on our website.
>
> We have sent the following release out:
>
> FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
>
> April 17, 2006
>
>
> "Draft Rudy" Campaign Goes on the Attack Against "Giuliani Time"
> Campaign Group Issues `Action Alert' Calling For Donations to
Launch
> A Campaign to Expose Inaccuracies in Film
>
>
> LOS ANGELES – With a month to go before the release of "Giuliani
> Time," Giuliani backers have put out an email Action Alert calling
> for subscribers "to launch an effective campaign to expose the
> inaccuracies in "Giuliani Time" and defend America's Mayor,"
> following the announcement of the documentary's theatrical release
> plans last week. On Monday, Allen Fore, co-founder of the Draft
Rudy
> For President, NFP (www.draftrudygiuliani.com) based in Chicago,
> Illinois, called for campaign donation of "$20, $200, or
$2,000...to
> combat and expose this propaganda that is being disguised as a
> documentary."
>
> Plans for the film's theatrical release were announced last week.
> National news outlets including the New York Times, New York Post
and
> MSNBC's "The Situation" with Tucker Carlson along with New York
> regional media such as the Daily News, WCBS, NY1's "Inside City
Hall"
> and WABC covered the story extensively. Patrick Healy of the New
> York Times called the film "Nothing less than a full frontal
assault
> on the civic deification of Rudolph W. Giuliani." David
> Saltonstall's column in the New York Daily News opines that the
> film "seeks to do for Giuliani what Michael Moore's `Farenheit
9/11'
> did for President Bush." The New York Post took aim at the "leftie
> flick." Director Kevin Keating was interviewed live on
MSNBC's "The
> Situation" with Tucker Carlson, on WCBS by Andrew Kirtzman, TV
> journalist and author of "Emperor of the City," one of the first
> books on Giuliani's term as mayor, and on "Inside City Hall" by
> Dominic Carter, who covered City Hall during Giuliani's reign.
>
> In the Action Alert, the "Draft Rudy" organization claims the
> film "tries to distort reality and ruin the reputation of an
American
> hero." Keating's film analyzes Giuliani's family history, his
> disastrous record on the First Amendment, the use and abuse of
> government powers and the severe methods he employed to enforce the
> Quality of Life and Zero Tolerance campaigns in New York City. In
> making the film, director Kevin Keating researched the film for
four
> years, shot approximately 300 hours of footage and culled through
> another 200 hours of network and archival footage. The filmmakers
> interviewed key people who worked with Giuliani's administration as
> well as long-time Giuliani advocates from the Manhattan Institute
> (Myron Magnet and Heather McDonald), George Kelling and Fred
> Siegel. The film features interviews with former New York City
> Police Commissioner William S. Bratton, former New York City School
> Commissioner Rudy Grew, and Wayne Barrett, the Village Voice's
Senior
> Editor who has written extensively on Giuliani ("Rudy!: An
> Investigative Biography of Rudolph Giuliani"). "The movie does
track
> sections from my book," says Barrett. "When the book came out in
> 2000, it was covered extensively by the media and Giuliani was
> challenged directly about what the book revealed. None of the
facts
> presented in the book were questioned by Giuliani."
>
> The film will open in New York at the Landmark's Sunshine Cinema on
> May 12 and widen to select theaters across the country. Cinema
Libre
> Studio has worldwide rights. For more information about the film
> visit www.giulianitime.com.
>
>
> FOR MORE INFORMATION:
>
>
> Draft Rudy Campaign - http://www.draftrudygiuliani.com/
>
>
> · From Wikipedia: "Draft Rudy Giuliani for President, Inc.,
> [23] registered with Federal Election Commission in October 2005 to
> become the first federal committee formed with the sole purpose of
> encouraging former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani to run for
President
> of the United States in 2008. As of January 2006, it remains the
only
> committee formed for this reason. By law, Draft Rudy Giuliani for
> President cannot coordinate its activities with the former mayor."
>
>
>
> · Action Alert posted at: www.giulianitime.com
>
>
>
> ABOUT CINEMA LIBRE STUDIO:
>
> Cinema Libre Studio is a haven for independent filmmakers with
views,
> offering one-stop shopping for production, co-production,
> distribution, foreign sales, marketing, and post-production
services.
> Headquartered in Los Angeles, the company is best known for
> distributing in theaters and on DVD titles that
> include "Outfoxed," "Uncovered," Tim Robbins' "Embedded
> Live," "Giuliani Time" and "Through the Fire." Several Cinema Libre
> Studio productions currently in festivals have recently won awards
> including "Conventioneers,"(Winner of the 2006 Independent Spirit
> Awards `John Cassavetes' Award (best feature under $500,000) and
Best
> Feature at the Miami International Film Festival), "The Empire in
> Africa," won Best Documentary at Slamdance 2006, and "Giuliani
Time"
> won Best Documentary art the SilverLake Film Festical. For more
> information visit www.cinemalibrestudio.com.
>
>
> EDITORS AND PRODUCERS:
>
> If you are interested in receiving a screener or to schedule an
> interview with director Kevin Keating, please contact Mary Keeler
at
> mkeeler@... or call 818-349-8822.
>
>
> To download images and other information, please visit
> www.giulianitime.com.
>
>
> - 30 -
>
With 928 days left until the 2008 election, it might seem a little early for the unveiling of "Giuliani Time," the seemingly Swift Boat-esque hit film that opens next month (Power Plays hasn't seen it yet). But thanks to the ever-advancing presidential campaign calendar, there's already a skeletal pro-Rudy organization ready to fight back. In fact, there are several of them.
Earlier this week, Draft Rudy Giuliani sent an "urgent message" to its adherents warning that the film "tries to distort reality and ruin the reputation of an American hero. . . . Whether you can give $20, $200, or $2,000, your support will be used to combat and expose this propaganda that is being disguised as a documentary." The message comes from Illinois political consultant and former state GOP official Allan Fore, who created draftrudygiuliani.com last October. That was 15 months after another site, Draft Giuliani, started operations. That site features the slogan "America's Mayor for America's President"-a phrase so groovy that they've trademarked it-as well as merchandise, like T-shirts for dogs.
Fore has also started an FEC-registered committee, called Draft Rudy Giuliani For President NFP. According to FEC records, the committee (which is not authorized by the candidate) has recorded a single donation-$500 in December from a man in Bridgehampton. (There are also draft committees for Hillary and Al Gore. And there's a Draft Michael Jackson King Of Pop For VP 2008 Campaign Committee.)
Despite the panic over at Draft Rudy Giuliani, "Giuliani Time" is probably the least of Rudy's worries if he's really contemplating a run for the White House. There's that McCain dude, whom everyone seems to love, and that Kerik fellow, the Rudy acolyte who blew up in the president's face. And there's the right wing of the Republican Party, with which Rudy has often disagreed on abortion, immigrants, gays, and other stuff.
Right now oddsmakers have Rudy facing 10-1 odds of being our next president, same as Virginia Governor Mark Warner and Veep runner-up John Edwards. Hillary, McCain, and Virginia Senator George Allen are seen as more likely winners. Condeleezza, George Pataki, John Kerry, and Jeb Bush are among the longer shots.
Will "Giuliani Time" help or hurt Rudy's chances? Draft Rudy Giuliani asked the same question. Seventy-nine percent of the 140 respondents said, "Yes, it'll help raise money that will support Rudy Giuliani." Ka-ching!
If ever anyone doubted that Giuliani
is a man of no principles who will lie about his views to fit his
political need, this proves it. Pro-Gay Giuliani, the infamous
cross-dresser who bunked with a gay couple after dumping his wife,
stumps for one of the most anti-Gay Republicans ...
There are signs
that former New York City mayor Rudy Giuliani may be
trying to distance himself from his reputation for
supporting abortion rights and gay equality as he eyes
a possible run for the Republican presidential
nomination in 2008. In a 1999 Interview with CNN's Inside
Politics, then-mayor Giuliani said, "I'm
pro-choice. I'm pro–gay rights"
But as the
midterm election draws near and Giuliani gets closer to what
many believe will be a shot at the presidency, the former
mayor is campaigning for some very antichoice,
anti–gay rights GOP candidates. Some political
experts say he's "mending fences."
On Tuesday,
Giuliani appeared at a rally for U.S. senator Rick Santorum
of Pennsylvania, a vocal opponent of gay rights, who has
said that states should regulate homosexuality "the
same as they regulate human sexual contact with
animals." Giuliani said of Santorum, "In any age you
don't have many leaders. Senator Santorum is one of them."
The New York Times reports that Giuliani will
head to Iowa later this month to campaign for U.S.
representative and gubernatorial candidate Jim Nussle.
Nussle is also an opponent of gay rights, having voted
for the federal constitutional ban on same-sex
marriage in 2004 and a ban on adoptions by gays in
Washington, D.C., in 1999. Iowa is also home of the
first national presidential caucus—and one of
the first stops for most presidential candidates.
And earlier this
week former Christian Coalition leader Ralph Reed
announced that Giuliani would headline a fund-raiser in
May for Reed's campaign for lieutenant governor of
Georgia. (Sirius OutQ News)
If ever anyone doubted that Giuliani
is a man of no principles who will lie about his views to fit his
political need, this proves it. Pro-Gay Giuliani, the infamous
cross-dresser who bunked with a gay couple after dumping his wife,
stumps for one of the most anti-Gay Republicans ...
There are signs
that former New York City mayor Rudy Giuliani may be
trying to distance himself from his reputation for
supporting abortion rights and gay equality as he eyes
a possible run for the Republican presidential
nomination in 2008. In a 1999 Interview with CNN's Inside
Politics, then-mayor Giuliani said, "I'm
pro-choice. I'm pro–gay rights"
But as the
midterm election draws near and Giuliani gets closer to what
many believe will be a shot at the presidency, the former
mayor is campaigning for some very antichoice,
anti–gay rights GOP candidates. Some political
experts say he's "mending fences."
On Tuesday,
Giuliani appeared at a rally for U.S. senator Rick Santorum
of Pennsylvania, a vocal opponent of gay rights, who has
said that states should regulate homosexuality "the
same as they regulate human sexual contact with
animals." Giuliani said of Santorum, "In any age you
don't have many leaders. Senator Santorum is one of them."
The New York Times reports that Giuliani will
head to Iowa later this month to campaign for U.S.
representative and gubernatorial candidate Jim Nussle.
Nussle is also an opponent of gay rights, having voted
for the federal constitutional ban on same-sex
marriage in 2004 and a ban on adoptions by gays in
Washington, D.C., in 1999. Iowa is also home of the
first national presidential caucus—and one of
the first stops for most presidential candidates.
And earlier this
week former Christian Coalition leader Ralph Reed
announced that Giuliani would headline a fund-raiser in
May for Reed's campaign for lieutenant governor of
Georgia. (Sirius OutQ News)
hey friends,
check out www.giulianitime.com Get Involved page - we posted some
banners and the trailer.
Also, the "Draft Rudy" campaign sent out an Action Alert on Monday
asking for money donation to combat "GIULIANI TIME" - there's a link
to the action alert posted on our website.
We have sent the following release out:
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
April 17, 2006
"Draft Rudy" Campaign Goes on the Attack Against "Giuliani Time"
Campaign Group Issues `Action Alert' Calling For Donations to Launch
A Campaign to Expose Inaccuracies in Film
LOS ANGELES – With a month to go before the release of "Giuliani
Time," Giuliani backers have put out an email Action Alert calling
for subscribers "to launch an effective campaign to expose the
inaccuracies in "Giuliani Time" and defend America's Mayor,"
following the announcement of the documentary's theatrical release
plans last week. On Monday, Allen Fore, co-founder of the Draft Rudy
For President, NFP (www.draftrudygiuliani.com) based in Chicago,
Illinois, called for campaign donation of "$20, $200, or $2,000...to
combat and expose this propaganda that is being disguised as a
documentary."
Plans for the film's theatrical release were announced last week.
National news outlets including the New York Times, New York Post and
MSNBC's "The Situation" with Tucker Carlson along with New York
regional media such as the Daily News, WCBS, NY1's "Inside City Hall"
and WABC covered the story extensively. Patrick Healy of the New
York Times called the film "Nothing less than a full frontal assault
on the civic deification of Rudolph W. Giuliani." David
Saltonstall's column in the New York Daily News opines that the
film "seeks to do for Giuliani what Michael Moore's `Farenheit 9/11'
did for President Bush." The New York Post took aim at the "leftie
flick." Director Kevin Keating was interviewed live on MSNBC's "The
Situation" with Tucker Carlson, on WCBS by Andrew Kirtzman, TV
journalist and author of "Emperor of the City," one of the first
books on Giuliani's term as mayor, and on "Inside City Hall" by
Dominic Carter, who covered City Hall during Giuliani's reign.
In the Action Alert, the "Draft Rudy" organization claims the
film "tries to distort reality and ruin the reputation of an American
hero." Keating's film analyzes Giuliani's family history, his
disastrous record on the First Amendment, the use and abuse of
government powers and the severe methods he employed to enforce the
Quality of Life and Zero Tolerance campaigns in New York City. In
making the film, director Kevin Keating researched the film for four
years, shot approximately 300 hours of footage and culled through
another 200 hours of network and archival footage. The filmmakers
interviewed key people who worked with Giuliani's administration as
well as long-time Giuliani advocates from the Manhattan Institute
(Myron Magnet and Heather McDonald), George Kelling and Fred
Siegel. The film features interviews with former New York City
Police Commissioner William S. Bratton, former New York City School
Commissioner Rudy Grew, and Wayne Barrett, the Village Voice's Senior
Editor who has written extensively on Giuliani ("Rudy!: An
Investigative Biography of Rudolph Giuliani"). "The movie does track
sections from my book," says Barrett. "When the book came out in
2000, it was covered extensively by the media and Giuliani was
challenged directly about what the book revealed. None of the facts
presented in the book were questioned by Giuliani."
The film will open in New York at the Landmark's Sunshine Cinema on
May 12 and widen to select theaters across the country. Cinema Libre
Studio has worldwide rights. For more information about the film
visit www.giulianitime.com.
FOR MORE INFORMATION:
Draft Rudy Campaign - http://www.draftrudygiuliani.com/
· From Wikipedia: "Draft Rudy Giuliani for President, Inc.,
[23] registered with Federal Election Commission in October 2005 to
become the first federal committee formed with the sole purpose of
encouraging former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani to run for President
of the United States in 2008. As of January 2006, it remains the only
committee formed for this reason. By law, Draft Rudy Giuliani for
President cannot coordinate its activities with the former mayor."
· Action Alert posted at: www.giulianitime.com
ABOUT CINEMA LIBRE STUDIO:
Cinema Libre Studio is a haven for independent filmmakers with views,
offering one-stop shopping for production, co-production,
distribution, foreign sales, marketing, and post-production services.
Headquartered in Los Angeles, the company is best known for
distributing in theaters and on DVD titles that
include "Outfoxed," "Uncovered," Tim Robbins' "Embedded
Live," "Giuliani Time" and "Through the Fire." Several Cinema Libre
Studio productions currently in festivals have recently won awards
including "Conventioneers,"(Winner of the 2006 Independent Spirit
Awards `John Cassavetes' Award (best feature under $500,000) and Best
Feature at the Miami International Film Festival), "The Empire in
Africa," won Best Documentary at Slamdance 2006, and "Giuliani Time"
won Best Documentary art the SilverLake Film Festical. For more
information visit www.cinemalibrestudio.com.
EDITORS AND PRODUCERS:
If you are interested in receiving a screener or to schedule an
interview with director Kevin Keating, please contact Mary Keeler at
mkeeler@... or call 818-349-8822.
To download images and other information, please visit
www.giulianitime.com.
- 30 -
To really get the significance of this new scandal in context you need
to know some background on Giuliani. His father was a Mafia enforcer
for a loan shark. Numerous of his uncles and close relatives were also
in the mob. His police commissioner on 9/11, Bernard Kerik, is right
now being investigated for having numerous ties to the Mafia. Giuliani and
his staff have routinely bragged that they copied the structure of the
Mafia as a basis for the Giuliani administration. Following the Times
article are a few of hundreds of pre-911 media quotes on the Giuliani-Mafia connection. -RL
NY Times
April 15, 2006
For Ex-F.B.I. Agent Accused in Murders, a Case of What Might Have Been
R. Lindley DeVecchio once stood atop the New York office of the
F.B.I. as a legendary Mafia hunter, a storied agent who helped break the back of the mob in the celebrated Commission Case.
Now he stands accused of helping the mob commit murders, charged in
a state indictment last month with feeding lethal secrets to a captain
of organized crime.
Mr. DeVecchio has been hailed as a hero and tarnished as a scourge,
and yet there was a moment in a Pennsylvania parking lot 30 years ago
that almost caused him to be neither.
In 1976, as a young F.B.I. agent, Mr. DeVecchio sold old handguns
to undercover officers, who later sought to charge him with a felony.
Had he been convicted, the case might have led to prison or his
dismissal as an agent. But Mr. DeVecchio, who said he acted legally and
to benefit a widow, was neither jailed nor fired.
The case against him was ultimately discarded without an indictment
by officials at the highest levels of the Justice Department, a
decision that the federal prosecutor in the original case says was
largely made by the top aide to the deputy United States attorney
general, a 32-year-old attorney named
Rudolph W. Giuliani
.
"Rudy expressed no other reason not to prosecute the guy except the
guy was a cop," said the former prosecutor, Daniel M. Clements, who is
now in private practice. "And he didn't want to embarrass the bureau."
Mr. Clements said last week that he recalled in detail his meetings
30 years ago with Mr. Giuliani, as well as his frustration that the
case was dismissed as unimportant.
Mr. Giuliani, who built a reputation in part by prosecuting corrupt
police officers, said through a spokeswoman, Sunny Mindel, that he had
no recollection of the DeVecchio case.
Whatever the level, if any, of Mr. Giuliani's role, the case stands
as a long-buried piece of law enforcement history, a fork in the road
that, if traversed differently, may have led to an entirely different
set of consequences. Indeed, from the vantage point of 1976, the gun
case may have seemed a minor matter. There was no way to know that
seven years later, according to the state indictment filed last month
in Brooklyn, Mr. DeVecchio would step across the line, helping a Mafia
informant kill at least four people.
But if Mr. DeVecchio had been pursued in 1976, would he have risen
to lead the F.B.I. squad that hunted the Colombo crime family? Would he
have had a role in some of the government's watershed cases against the
mob? Would he now stand accused of second-degree murder?
His lawyer, Douglas E. Grover, said federal officials were right to
never charge his client in the gun case because they were merely
antiques that were peddled at a gun show. But he acknowledged that had
that case been successfully pursued Mr. DeVecchio would probably have
lost his job. "It also means that they may made not have made the
Commission Case," he said, referring to a 1986 trial at which top
organized crime leaders in New York City were convicted.
The gun case began in early 1976 when Mr. DeVecchio traveled from
New York to King of Prussia, Pa., to sell a Nazi-era Luger at the
Valley Forge Gun Show, which promotes itself as "a gun show in the
truest American tradition."
He was looking, according to his testimony in a later case, to sell
the weapons "for the benefit of the widow" to whom they belonged.
Without a license, he moved through the stalls of the firearms
bazaar, and was soon approached by Michael Flax, an undercover agent
with the Federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, Mr. Flax
said. Mr. Flax's job was to troll the show in plainclothes looking for
such illicit deals. That year alone, he said, several people he caught
similarly selling guns without paperwork went to prison. "I was usually
like, 'Gee I'd like to get this gun,' " he said in an interview from
his retirement home in San Diego. ' "Do we have to go through all the
paperwork?' "
Mr. Flax recalled that he bought the Luger in a parking lot outside
the show. Over several weeks, he said, he pursued an investigation of
Mr. DeVecchio in which a second agent secretly recorded the F.B.I. man
selling another gun. He said that Mr. DeVecchio, at one point, gave him
a phone number at which he might be reached. It was, he said, an office
of the New York F.B.I.
A few weeks later, Mr. Flax brought the case to Mr. Clements, then
a young federal prosecutor in Baltimore. Mr. Clements is now in private
practice and active in the Democratic Party, having given money to
candidates like
John Kerry and
Al Gore.
"Flax comes to me saying, 'You're not going to believe this,' " Mr.
Clements said last week. " 'I have an F.B.I. agent selling guns
illegally.' "
A few months later, Mr. Clements said he told the F.B.I. as a
courtesy that he was investigating one of its agents. A few weeks
passed, he said, with discussions back and forth with F.B.I. officials
in Maryland and in Washington. "The next person I heard from," he went
on, "was Rudolph Giuliani."
Mr. Giuliani was, at that point, an aide to Harold Tyler, the deputy
attorney general, who reviewed such cases. Mr. Giuliani had joined his
staff in 1975 after serving in the United States attorney's office in
Manhattan where he had helped direct the prosecution in the Prince of
the City police corruption case.
Over several weeks, Mr. Clements said, Mr. Giuliani asked him to
write a pair of memoranda on the case in which he noted that Mr.
DeVecchio had sold the guns without the proper paperwork, a crime, Mr.
Clements said, for which he thought there was sufficient evidence to
prosecute. Mr. Clements said he attended a pair of meetings about the
case with Mr. Giuliani, including one in Mr. Giuliani's office also
attended by Mr. Tyler and Jervis Finney, the United States attorney in
Maryland who was then Mr. Clements's boss.
Mr. Finney, now the chief lawyer for the governor of Maryland, said
last week he has no recollection of the meeting. But Mr. Clements
produced a datebook he said he had saved that listed a meeting with Mr.
Giuliani in June 1976.
At that meeting and a subsequent meeting in October, Mr. Clements
said Mr. Giuliani repeated his desire not to prosecute the case, saying
the guns were old and the sale of them without paperwork did not
warrant prosecution.
Judge Tyler, who Mr. Clements said was at the second meeting, died
last year. The bottom line, after both meetings, Mr. Clements said, was
that the case would be dropped.
In the ensuing years, Mr. DeVecchio rose to lead the F.B.I.'s
special unit that investigates the Colombo crime family, a position in
which he had success in part because of his relationship with a captain
in the family, Gregory Scarpa Sr., who became his informant.
The closeness of that relationship ultimately led to a two-year
inquiry of Mr. DeVecchio by the F.B.I. that ended in 1996 with the
decision to bring no charges against him. But Mr. DeVecchio soon
retired.
In 1997, the old gun case briefly resurfaced. At a federal appeals
hearing in Brooklyn. Mr. DeVecchio was called as a witness by a
gangster, Victor J. Orena, who was trying to win his freedom by
suggesting that Mr. DeVecchio was a corrupt agent who had lied about
the facts in his case. Under questioning by Gerald Shargel, Mr. Orena's
lawyer, Mr. DeVecchio acknowledged selling the guns to the federal
agents.
Mr. Shargel then went on to ask him: "Do you remember agents of the
A.T.F. reporting to the F.B.I. and Rudolph Giuliani — not yet the mayor
— that you had lied to those agents who questioned you, that when
confronted with the crimes that you committed, you gave them false
exculpatory statements?"
Mr. DeVecchio said that he did not.
In the new indictment, announced last month by
Charles J. Hynes
,
the Brooklyn district attorney, Mr. DeVecchio is accused of helping Mr.
Scarpa commit at least four murders in the 1980's and early 1990's in
exchange for weekly payments. Most of the victims had been talking to
the authorities, prosecutors said, and thus were a threat to Mr. Scarpa.
When Mr. Clements read of the indictment, he said he was surprised.
At the same time, he recalled the words that he and Mr. Flax had
swapped, years ago, when the gun case, as he put it, "went away."
It was an old-time adage on those who break the law, a general
theory of recidivist crime. "If someone's a bad actor, we'll get him
again," he remembered telling Mr. Flax.
Thug Life The Shocking Secret History of Harold Giuliani, the Mayor�s Ex-Convict Dad
by Wayne Barrett July 5 - 11, 2000
The following is an excerpt from Rudy! An Investigative Biography of Rudolph Giuliani, which will be available in New York stores on July 11. It is printed by permission of the publisher, Basic Books.
�Harold Giuliani and Helen D'Avanzo met at a party in 1929 or 1930.
The roaring '20s had tapered to a whisper, the Great Depression had
recently cast its vast and wretched shadow, and Prohibition had long
ago confined much of the American social scene to speakeasies. It was
not an auspicious time for romance, and Harold and Helen's dating life
was typically austere: picnics in the park, moonlight strolls,
home-based dances and get-togethers. Occasionally, they would splurge
on a movie at Times Square�tickets were only 35 cents, if you bought
them before 5:30 p.m.
At 5'11", with a solid frame and big-knuckled hands, Harold
was a thickset ruffian who squinted at the world through cumbersome,
Coke-bottle-thick glasses. He had been trained as a part-time plumber's
assistant but had remained financially dependent on his parents into
early adulthood. Much of his childhood had been spent on the streets of
East Harlem, staving off boredom with stickball and other games. At age
15, he dropped out of high school and was soon arrested for burglary
and sentenced to probation in New York City Children's Court.
Emboldened by regular beatings from his father, he took up boxing and,
through a demonstration of sheer feral aggression, persuaded a local
trainer to condition him for a pro career. But because of poor vision,
Harold was kept out of the ring. Instead, he took his pugilistic
prowess to the streets, engaging in countless scuffles. Blinking behind
his half-inch-thick lenses, he would fling a flurry of punches, landing
them anywhere and everywhere, mercilessly hammering his opponent into
submission. The vision problem only compounded his volcanic temper,
mixed in with it, to create a sort of unalloyed, inexorable ferocity.
Taunting Harold with a typical teenage gibe like "four eyes" would
guarantee an immediate pummeling.
Shy and proper, Helen was the perfect antidote to Harold. She
was an excellent student who skipped two grades and graduated from high
school at the age of 16. A dark-featured southern Italian, she would
often bleach her hair blond for social occasions and loved dancing the
Charleston.
Throughout their seven-year courtship, Harold was a persistent
suitor and Helen a hesitant target. Most of her five brothers, at
first, turned up their noses at her inelegant beau, regarding him as a
poor match for their little sister. Helen harbored doubts of her own,
she later admitted, particularly when it came to Harold's "terrible
temper." She recalled one incident early in their courtship. "It was
about six months after we met and we were walking up 123rd Street," she
said. "He had his arm around me and when a car passed by, somebody in
it yelled, 'Ain't love grand!' The car stopped for a light and Harold
ran to the corner, pulled the guy out of the car, and boom! I yelled,
'Harold, what are you doing, you savage?' "
But it was not just Helen's honor he was protecting. If Harold
overheard a man on the street utter what he perceived to be a
disparaging remark about a woman, "Harold would smack the guy," Helen
said. These incidents became so common that Harold would affectionately
sign all his love letters with the sobriquet "your savage."
At least four years after they began dating, Harold truly
earned his nickname. In the spring of 1934, just a week after his 26th
birthday, jobless and restless, he resorted to desperate measures.
On April 5, the "savage" was arraigned on armed robbery and
assault charges in the Magistrate's Court for the City of New York and
ordered held on $5000 bail. Before Magistrate Alfred Lindau, Harold
Giuliani lied about his age and address, claiming he was 24 and lived
on East 84th Street. He also lied about his occupation, saying that he
was an electrician. When asked to identify himself, he told the court
that his name was Joseph Starrett.
On that day, Harold Giuliani (a/k/a Joseph Starrett) pleaded not guilty.
On April 12, in the case of People v. Harold Giuliani indicted as Joseph Starrett,
Giuliani was charged with four felonies: robbery in the first degree,
assault in the first degree, grand larceny in the second degree, and
criminally receiving stolen property.
The crime occurred on April 2, 1934, at 12:05 p.m. in the
unlit first-floor corridor of a 10-family residential building at 130
East 96th Street in Manhattan. Shortly before noon, Harold Giuliani and
an accomplice positioned themselves in shadowy recesses near the
stairwell. Within 10 or 15 minutes Harold Hall, a milkman for Borden's
Farms, entered the building to make routine payment collections. As he
began to make his way up the stairs, Giuliani emerged from the shadows
and, according to the indictment, pressed the muzzle of a pistol
against Hall's stomach. "You know what it is," he reportedly said. He
forced the man into a nook behind the stairwell, where his counterpart
was waiting. The other man plunged his hand into Hall's pants pocket
and fished out $128.82 in cash.
As Giuliani's accomplice frantically stuffed the money into
his own pockets, either he or Giuliani�or both�commanded Hall to "pull
down your pants."
Hall refused.
Giuliani grabbed Hall's pants and yanked them down to his
ankles. He told Hall to sit down. He grabbed the man's hands, pulled
them behind his back and bound them with cord. Squatting, his back to
the wall, Giuliani leaned over his victim and began tying his feet
together. Before he was finished, a police officer, Edward Schmitt,
burst in the front door of the building.
"Throw them up!" yelled Schmitt. Giuliani obeyed.
His accomplice, who, at this point, had the gun and the money,
fled down the stairs to the basement and escaped onto the street.
Schmitt collared Giuliani and took him to the 23rd Precinct.
The officer later told the judge assigned to that case that he had been
"tipped off by a citizen that a couple of fellows were hanging around
130 East 96th Street for about half an hour, and he finally saw them
going into the hallway. After they went in, a milkman went in, and the
citizen suspected that there was something wrong and he called me and
told me about it."
Although Giuliani's family didn't have the means to help him,
he had friends with resources. Three days after he was arrested, a man
named Valentine Spielman put up $5000 to bail him out. Spielman listed
his address as 351 East 60th in Manhattan.
On April 19, a week after the indictment was filed, Hall
changed his statement, telling a markedly different story. This time,
he said it was Giuliani's accomplice who had pressed the gun to his
stomach and said, "You know what it is."
During a hearing on May 23, Louis Capozzoli, an assistant
district attorney, told the judge that Hall altered his story only
after he was threatened. "This milkman tried to change his statement,"
noted Capozzoli, "after he was visited at about four o'clock that
morning by several people who threatened him. Then he said he thought
this fellow [Giuliani] ought to get a break."
Hall's coerced reversal may have been effective in reducing
his assailant's prison time. On May 9, before Judge Owen Bohan in the
Court of General Sessions, Giuliani switched his plea to guilty. He was
allowed, in light of Hall's altered statement, to plead to one count of
armed robbery in the third degree. While still a serious felony
conviction, armed robbery drew less prison time than a guilty plea on
any one of the original charges.
At Giuliani's sentencing hearing, his attorney, Robert J.
Fitzsimmons, appealed for leniency. "I believe this is the case that
warrants extreme clemency," said Fitzsimmons, who later explained: "The
defendant realizes his mistake. His home life has been of the finest
and he comes from a wonderful family."
Judge Bohan firmly replied, "I am a very sympathetic judge, but I have no sympathy for robbers with guns."
Fitzsimmons, yielding, acknowledged that his client "should get
some punishment to make him realize the seriousness of his act."
The judge then addressed Giuliani, bluntly asking, "Who is the other man that was in this thing with you?"
Officer Schmitt spoke up, telling the judge that Giuliani "gave
a fictitious name and address" and "refused to give us the name and
address of the other man."
Suddenly, Fitzsimmons announced the name of Giuliani's supposed
accomplice, Joseph Podemo. (No one named Joseph Podemo, however, was
charged in connection with this, or any other, crime between 1929 and
1935.)
The judge was suspicious of Fitzsimmons's remark. "I will
commit this defendant," he said. "If he wants to help himself, let him
tell us the name of the man who had the gun."
On May 29, Judge Bohan sentenced Harold Giuliani to two to five years at Sing Sing state prison.
According to Giuliani's "Receiving Blotter," obtained from Sing
Sing Prison, he started serving his time on May 31. The blotter form
requires answers to standard questions, such as height, weight, and
address. His address is listed as 313 East 123rd Street, across the
street from his parents' building at 354 East 123rd. The criminal act
for which Giuliani was sentenced is described as follows: "Held up man,
hallway,daytime, gun, money." The form indicates that his "habits" are
"temperate" and include "tobacco." He speaks "good" English, the
interviewer observed, and is also semifluent in Italian. His religion
is noted as Catholic, and his church attendance is described as
"occasional." His alias is listed as Joseph Starrett.
When asked by the interviewer to what he "attributed" his
criminal acts, Giuliani answered "unemployment." He listed two
employers under "Employment Record." The first mentioned was Koch
Plumbing, where he earned a weekly wage of $30 as a "plumber's helper."
But his 1934 employment at Koch lasted only two weeks. The second
employer, John N. Kapp, also a plumber, hired Giuliani at a weekly wage
of $24 and kept him on from 1929�around the time he met Helen�until
1932. Giuliani described no other employment.
Two weeks before he was committed to Sing Sing, Giuliani
underwent a psychiatric exam. Benjamin Apfelberg, a psychiatrist with
the city's Department of Hospitals, sent his report to Judge Bohan on
May 18. Although Apfelberg found that Giuliani was "not mentally
defective" and displayed "no psychotic symptoms at the present time,"
the report painted a troubling mental portrait.
"A study of this individual's makeup," wrote Apfelberg,
"reveals that he is a personality deviate of the aggressive, egocentric
type. This aggressivity is pathological in nature and has shown itself
from time to time even as far back as his childhood. He is egocentric
to an extent where he has failed to consider the feelings and rights of
others."
Noting Harold's "nearsightedness," Apfelberg continued: "As a
result of this physical handicap, especially because of taunts in his
boyhood years, he has developed a sense of inferiority which, in recent
years, has become accentuated on account of his prolonged idleness and
dependence on his parents. . . . His school life was marked by
retardation on account of the mischievous and unruly conduct. Due to
his aggressive traits and through his excessive aimless idleness, he
has been attracted to haphazard associations which apparently were the
direct precipitating factors in bringing about the present offense. He
is anxious about his predicament on account of a feeling of guilt. He
rationalizes the motives of his offense in a self-pitying way in order
to obtain sympathy."
Apfelberg concluded his report with this recommendation and
caveat: "From a purely and strictly psychiatric standpoint, without
considering the social, environmental and other factors in this case,
the findings indicate that the social rehabilitation possibilities are
favorable for eventual readjustment but are rather dubious as to the
prognosis in regard to improvement in personality."
After a year and a half at Sing Sing State Prison, Harold
Giuliani was released on September 24, 1935. A year later, while on
parole, he married his long-courted sweetheart, Helen D'Avanzo, at St.
Francis of Assisi Church in Brooklyn. On May 5, 1939, more than two
years after he and his new wife had moved into a house they shared with
her mother, he completed his parole.
It took the Giulianis six years and one miscarriage to have a
baby. "Helen had the miscarriage early in the marriage," recalled Anna
D'Avanzo, one of Helen's sisters-in-law. "The next time I saw her, she
was crying. Harold always looked at the good side, 'We'll have another
one.' " Eventually, Harold was right. On Sunday, May 28, 1944, Helen,
age 35, gave birth to her long-awaited and only child, Rudolph William
Louis Giuliani. After receiving the news, Harold frantically ran up and
down the steps of every building on his block, handing out cigars.
Named after his grandfather Rodolfo, little Rudy (then spelled Rudi)
was considered by his verging-on-middle-age parents to be a blessing
from God, an answer to countless prayers.
It was Helen's mother, Adelina D'Avanzo, who spent the most
time with "the little prince," as some relatives referred to him.
Adelina was not only the Giulianis' emotional bedrock; she was also the
family's financial foundation. She owned 419 Hawthorne Street, the
building in East Flatbush, Brooklyn, to which Harold and Helen had
returned that Sunday with their newborn. A modest, two-family red and
tan brick house, 419 was indistinguishable from all the others in the
unbroken, block-long row of fused-together buildings between New York
and Brooklyn avenues. Harold, Helen, Adelina, and Rudy lived on the
second floor, in a narrow, six-room apartment with parquet floors,
decorative moldings in the plaster walls, and high ceilings.
At the time of Rudy's birth, Harold was working in the Brooklyn
Navy Yard as a plumber's assistant, the trade he had learned before
prison. World War II had lasted more than four and a half years. D Day
was just nine days away. Headlines had then heralded a "Nazi Escape
Road" into Europe. The only member of either the Giuliani or D'Avanzo
family who served in the war was Harold's brother Charles, stationed in
New Guinea for four years until 1948. Harold's younger brother,
Rudolph, born on December 13, 1926, was too young to be drafted. Four
of Helen's brothers were excused from service because they were cops;
her youngest brother, Roberto, entered the police force on November 21,
1942, in the middle of the war.
Harold told relatives and friends that he wasn't drafted
because of his poor eyesight and ulcers. What, in truth, protected him
from military service, however, was his criminal record. The record was
almost impossible to find�then and now�because it is filed in the name
of Joseph Starrett. Harold apparently helped the local draft board
locate it.
On April 18, 1941, Morris S. Ganchrow, secretary of the
Selective Service System's Local Board #217 in Brooklyn, wrote a letter
to the Court of General Session, inquiring into Harold's criminal
background. The letter read:
Dear Gentlemen:
We understand that Harold Angelo Giuliani, using the alias
"Joseph Starrett," a registrant in this Board, was convicted of
Attempted Robbery, 3rd degree, on April 24, 1934.
In order that he may be properly classified by members of
this Board, will you please give us the details of his Court Record, as
to the charge�whether a misdemeanor or a felony, and if sentenced, the
period he was confined.
Enclosed is self-addressed envelope for reply.
The charge was, of course, a felony, and anyone guilty of a felony was barred from wartime service.
The D'Avanzos and Giulianis still discussed the Allies' great
campaign over dinner. The fact that their homeland was an Axis country
did not diminish Helen Giuliani's sense of patriotism. "Helen was a
little sticking up for the Italians, a little on the Italian side,"
recalled Anna. "She liked Mussolini and things like that."
On July 2, 1944, just a few days over a month old, Rudy was
baptized at St. Francis of Assisi Church on the corner of Lincoln and
Nostrand avenues, six blocks away from his home. Although Rudy's father
was reputed to pray every night before a small altar on the dresser top
in his room, his wife and mother-in-law were not as enthusiastic or
routine about their worship. On Sunday mornings, Helen would escort
Rudy to mass, but allegedly only on Harold's orders. Harold's
sister-in-law Evelyn Giuliani recalled that Helen was "not very
religious."
At five years old, Rudy was enrolled in the church's
kindergarten�if not solely for the religion, then for a generous dose
of discipline. Founded in 1909, the school served children of the
parish, providing stern, regimented instruction from kindergarten
through eighth grade. Wrist rappings and ear boxings were as
commonplace then as detentions and demerits.
One afternoon in 1948, as Helen's younger brother Leo (a/k/a Tullio)
D'Avanzo was coasting down Kingston Avenue in Brooklyn in his taxi,
hunting for customers, he noticed that an old neighborhood bar on the
corner of Kingston and Rutland had been closed. He talked to the owner
of the building, Philomena Mandelino and, within a few months, made a
bold career move: He bought the bar and reopened it. The deed to the
property wasn't filed in his name, though; it was listed under his
wife's name, Veronica "Betty" D'Avanzo. And the business license wasn't
in his name either; that was conveniently registered under the name of
his brother Vincent D'Avanzo, who happened to be a patrolman in the
67th Precinct. Since nothing was ever in Leo's name, the reincarnated
watering hole was named after Vincent.
With ornate tin ceilings and a commodious dining area that
stretched nearly half a block, Vincent's Restaurant could accommodate
upwards of 150 revelers. A 12-block walk from Ebbetts Field, it was
located in what was known in the '30s as "pig town"�a poor, highly
populated area in which many Italian immigrants raised pigs in the
yards of their often ramshackle, makeshift homes. Convenient and
familiar, Vincent's drew a hearty clientele of firemen, fishermen,
bookies, sanitation workers, and others. The bar was also a roost for a
roster of wizened regulars, sardonic old Italian and Irish guys who
drank rye whiskey with rock candy and had nicknames like Ippy and
Stumpy.
Most important, Vincent's Restaurant became the headquarters
of Leo D'Avanzo's loan-sharking and gambling operations, ventures he
ran with a partner, Jimmy Dano, who was a made man. Dano had once
worked as a runner for the powerful numbers-racket operator and
narcotics distributor James (Jimmy the Clam) Eppolito. He and Leo had a
secret wire room tucked in the back of Vincent's and employed a small
army of as many as 15 runners. "There was a lot of booking and numbers
and all that nonsense," said Leo's former mistress of nearly 30 years,
Elizabeth Mandelino, who was the daughter of the prior owner,
Philomena. (The Mandelinos were related by marriage to the Eppolitos).
"That's how they survived."
And in East Flatbush, Brooklyn, it was Leo's show. If you
needed money, you went to Leo. If you wanted to place a bet on a horse,
he was the man to see. "Everybody in Flatbush knew Leo," said
Mandelino, who had lived in an apartment above Vincent's with her
mother and would later move into a nearby eight-family apartment
building Leo bought on Beverly Road.
Tall and thin, with fingernails as white as piano keys, Leo
D'Avanzo was an immaculate dresser, hair never out of place, shoes
always freshly shined. Often taking drags on a cigarette�he smoked a
pack a day easily�he would tell his mistress about his shylocking
business and extorting people and having to "break their legs." But
he'd never kill anyone, he assured the woman 16 years his junior. He'd
never kill for money.
In family circles, Uncle Leo was the shadowy black sheep.
"Everybody in the family said, 'Don't be like Leo,' " recalled Rudy's
cousin Gina Gialoreta. "Leo was Mafia, bad, bad. . . . Uncle Leo lived
by his wits�that's what my grandmother used to say."
On August 17, 1951, at age 38, Leo was arraigned in Brooklyn
Criminal Court on felony "criminal receiving" charges, but the case was
eventually dismissed. Seven years later, in April 1958, he appeared in
Brooklyn Gambler's Court, arraigned on bets and bookmaking charges; he
put up a $500 bond and was discharged by Judge Anthony Livoti.
Even Leo's cop brother Vincent found himself on the receiving
end of an arrest on a few occasions. On October 15, 1954, he was
arraigned in Gambler's Court on minor charges related to the Alcohol
Beverage Control Act, but was discharged. On February 14, 1961, Vincent
was arrested with 12 other defendants by an officer from his brother
Roberto's precinct, the 71st, for a violation of the New York City
administrative code that appeared to be related to gambling; given a
choice in district court between one day in jail and a $2 fine, Vincent
paid the fine.
Since New York State criminal records before 1970 are not
computerized and, therefore, either unavailable or extremely hard to
locate, these incidents may not represent the totality of Leo
D'Avanzo's criminal career.
Behind the mahogany bar at Vincent's Restaurant, puffing on a
cigar while he drew pints and fixed cocktails, was Harold Giuliani. The
40-year-old father of a four-year-old son had a patchwork employment
history of a few on-again, off-again jobs. Nearly two years after
prison, in July 1937, at the age of 29, Harold had applied for a Social
Security number, listing his job status as "unemployed." At some point
in the late '30s or early '40s, he tried his hand at door-to-door
salesmanship, hawking tablecloths and bedspreads, before going on to
work briefly at the Navy Yard. Now what Harold needed most was security
and a weekly paycheck. The one man who could provide both was his
brother-in-law, whose illegal operations were fronted by his other
brother-in-law, the cop. "My father-in-law [Leo] was kind of close with
Harold," noted Lois D'Avanzo, who would later marry Leo's son Lewis.
Like his brothers-in-law, Harold was a snappy dresser, usually
attired in a starched shirt and tie and wearing a hat. Relatives
described him as an affectionate man, who hugged as tight as a vise and
kissed old ladies and children. Because of his stomach ulcers, the
gray-eyed, bespectacled bartender often drank milk while his customers
knocked back scotch. In case anyone got too rowdy, he kept a baseball
bat behind the bar and a .38 caliber pistol next to the cash register.
An opinionated and voluble Yankees fan in Dodgers-land, a man who
reputedly hated most politicians, Harold would engage in heated
arguments with his customers, his voice booming sometimes out into the
street. If there was a bar fight, it was Harold who broke it up. If a
customer had let his tab go for too long, it was Harold who went with
his baseball bat to collect.
But bar tabs weren't the only debts Harold collected. He had
come a long way since the spring day more than 14 years ago when he
mugged a milkman. Now the crimes he committed were part of an organized
criminal enterprise. Known as the "muscle" behind the loan-sharking
operation, Harold was Leo's collection agent, recouping money that had
been loaned out and was now overdue.
Most debtors would pay at the bar, slipping an envelope to
Harold across the counter. In the mid to late '50s, Harold collected as
much as $15,000 a week, tapping dozens of debtors. The "vig" usually
began at a stifling 150 percent and rose with the passing of each week.
Many people borrowed money to pay rent or foot a business expense and
would pay back four or five times the amount they borrowed. There were
no excuses for being late.
One afternoon, a man reluctantly entered the bar to apologize
to Harold, saying that he didn't have the money�could he have just one
more week? Frowning, Harold reached under the bar, out of sight, and
gripped his baseball bat. As the man before him continued pleading for
an extension, Harold swung the bat, cracking him flat across the face,
sending him back a few feet. "Don't be late again," Harold said,
according to an eyewitness.
That was the gist of Harold's job: enforce Leo's law through
threats or violence. He shoved people against walls, broke legs,
smashed kneecaps, crunched noses. He gave nearby Kings County Hospital
a lot of business.
"People in the neighborhood were terrified of him," said a
frequent customer at Vincent's, who was one of Leo's son Lewis's best
friends and whose family borrowed money from Leo.*
He remembers what happened early one Saturday morning after his
own father failed to make a payment. "When I was a kid, my father
borrowed money from Leo," he said. "He couldn't pay, so Harold came to
collect. He knocked on the door and yelled, 'I want the money now, or
I'm going to break both your arms!' "
After Harold calmed down, an agreement was worked out. "They talked to Leo and straightened it out," he said.
While in high school, Lewis's friend did occasional chores
around the bar, and his brother took a job in the wire room, charting
bets on the numbers boards. Many years later, after opening his own
business, Lewis's friend borrowed $90,000 from Leo and paid back
$160,000, a fairly modest repayment total. "It would only take me four
to five weeks to pay him back," he said, adding that his brother once
borrowed $5000 and ended up paying back $20,000.
Gambling, loan-sharking, and booze weren't the only sources of
income at Vincent's. A black man who worked in the payroll office at a
local hospital would stop by the bar every week or so to give Harold
several dozen fake paychecks. The checks were made out to a host of
fictitious employees and were drawn on the hospital's bank account.
"Harold would cash them in the bar," said Lewis's friend. "There would
be several thousand dollars' worth of checks every week. Harold would
get half, and the black guy would get the other half."
Harold told his confidant, Jack O'Leary, A Christian Brother who was
one of Rudy's teachers, that one reason he left Brooklyn in 1951,
moving to Garden City, Long Island, was "to get away from my in-laws."
He didn't want his son exposed to what went on at the bar, he
explained, and vowed that his boy would not end up like Lewis, Leo's
boy, who hung around the numbers charts and lived with his family in
the apartment above the new bar.
Sometime in the late '50s, Harold stopped tending bar full-time
at Vincent's. On January 12, 1959, two and half months shy of his 51st
birthday and shortly before Rudy's 15th, Harold Giuliani got his first
on-the-books, legit job.He was hired for $3300 per year as a
groundskeeper for Lynbrook Public High School in Lynbrook, Long Island,
where Helen's younger brother Edward lived with his wife, Anna, and
their three children.
Perhaps in connection with that job, Harold requested
information about the cloud that had hung over him since 1934. A
notation in the General Sessions court file indicates he sought copies
of the "complaint and certification" of the criminal case against
Joseph Starrett. The notation lists Giuliani at his Garden City
address, indicating that copies of the key documents were sent to him
there.
As a member of the buildings and grounds crew for the Lynbrook
district, Harold spent his day maintaining sports equipment, buffing
the terrazzo marble floors, grooming athletic fields, and, in the
winter, salting parking lots and driveways.
In October 1959, the Giulianis migrated once again. Harold,
after only 10 months on the job at Lynbrook High School, took out a
$162-per-month mortgage on a new, comparably capacious split-level
ranch house in Bellmore, closer to Lynbrook. Fixed in a tidy row of
similar houses on a short block called Pine Court, the Giulianis' new
home, replete with a deck and a two-car garage, was Harold's castle.
Although open-minded and mild-mannered, Brother O'Leary was no softy
when it came to discipline. When Rudy made a wisecrack in the middle of
an afternoon lecture, his homeroom teacher marched over to the lisping
upstart and cuffed him on the side of the head. In October 1959, the
beginning of Rudy's junior year, at a Bishop Loughlin Memorial High
School open house, O'Leary was surprised when Harold and Helen Giuliani
tentatively approached him and thanked him for smacking their
irreverent son. "They asked me if I remembered the time I punished
Rudy. I said yes. They said, 'We want to thank you, because he became a
much better student after that.' "
From that encounter, a relationship blossomed. Since Rudy and
his friend Alan Placa were, in their earlier years, misbehaving to the
detriment of other students, O'Leary "would report to my father on my
conduct every week," Rudy said. This weekly check-in system soon
evolved into a friendship with the Giuliani family. The young Catholic
brother would join Rudy, his parents, and his grandmother for spaghetti
dinners at their house in Bellmore.
The devoted Catholic brother would become one of the most
important influences in Rudy's early life. "He was terrific," Rudy
said. "He spent a lot of time with me, developing interests that I had
that I wasn't comfortable about. Like reading and opera, things that I
wouldn't talk to my friends about, because they would think I was a
sissy."
Some evenings after dinner at the Giulianis', Harold, O'Leary,
and Rudy would excuse themselves and take a stroll in a nearby park.
They would discuss news, politics, matters of religion. Rudy might
prattle on about Jack Kennedy or jaw with his father and teacher about
the Yankees. Sometimes the high school senior would tread a few paces
ahead or lag a few paces behind, and when he was out of earshot, Harold
might broach other, more serious, matters with O'Leary. In the spring
of 1960, during one of these walks, while Rudy tagged behind them,
Harold made a sudden, cryptic confession to his confidant.
"I've done things in the past that I've paid for," Rudy's father said.
The men continued walking, wordlessly, the sounds of their feet
on the path suddenly loud in the wake of Harold's comment. Keeping
silent, O'Leary waited. He would let Harold offer an explanation, pour
his heart out if needed. And O'Leary was ready for whatever this hard,
vexed man had to tell him.
But Harold Giuliani said nothing more. As the dusk enclosed
them, Harold shunted the conversation back to generalities, and Rudy
caught up with them and the three sauntered together through the dark
back to the house.
The following fall, Harold Giuliani REceived a letter from Richard
P. McLean, the assistant superintendent of the Lynbrook Public Schools.
Dated December 7, 1961, the letter read:
We have heard no word from you concerning your return to
work in the Lynbrook Public Schools. The custodial staff is presently
shorthanded one man. May I ask that we resolve this issue as soon as
possible. . . . Your immediate response to this letter will be
appreciated.
McLean was writing Harold because he hadn't been to work in
months. Nearly two weeks after the first letter, the assistant
superintendent sent the 53-year-old, AWOL custodian a second letter,
terminating him.
Harold lost his job just as Rudy was finishing up his first
semester at Manhattan College. Asked a few months earlier�in his
February 1961 application for a scholarship from Italian American
Charities�what he planned to do if financial assistance was not
granted, Rudy had written: "My father will, of course, help to pay
towards my college education as much as he can. Then I expect to work
this summer. However, this will not be enough. I must, of necessity,
have some outside aid in order to complete my education." He had listed
his father's job as a custodian.
With scorching ulcers and a nascent heart problem, Harold
Giuliani was no longer the swaggering, hearty man readily disposed to
put the knuckles on someone for looking at his wife the wrong way. But
the reason he had failed to report to work since the previous spring
was not a physical one. "Harold had something of a nervous breakdown,"
explained his confidant Jack O'Leary. "He wasn't working at the time."
Harold told friends that one of the events that triggered his
breakdown was an incident in a Long Island state park in the spring of
1961. For the first time in many years, he was arrested, a chilling,
jolting experience that abruptly exhumed old memories. The offense was
trivial but embarrassing. Harold had long suffered from severe
constipation. One afternoon, while strolling in the park, he suddenly
felt the need to go. By his own account, when he found a public rest
room, he pulled his pants down and began doing deep knee bends outside
the stalls to expedite the process. A police officer happened to walk
in right then. Harold was arrested for "loitering" and hauled down to
the local police station. The charges were eventually dismissed, but
the experience haunted the 53-year-old.
"The last time I saw Harold," recalled O'Leary, "he was
practically bedridden. He was sitting out on a lawn chair in the
backyard all pale and terrible-looking."
In October 1978, Harold and Helen sold their split-level house in
Bellmore for $52,000 and rented a three-bedroom apartment in Bayside,
Queens, for $600 per month. A sedentary middle-class neighborhood,
their section of Bayside was populated with clusters of retired
Italians, Irish, and Germans. The Giulianis' apartment building on the
corner of 218th Street and Horace Harding Parkway would have been just
as peaceful and quiet as Pine Court if not for the relentless roar of
the Long Island Expressway less than 50 feet from the front door.
A friendly Italian couple, Joe and Lina Merli, owned the
building, living in the first-floor apartment. The Giulianis, who lived
upstairs, would often join the Merlis for dinner, bantering in Italian
over Lina's sprawling pasta feasts.
"Harold, he was so funny man, a very familiar person," recalled
Lina, an 82-year-old retired hotel housekeeper, who still struggles at
times with her English. On Saturday afternoons, Lina and Harold would
often share stories, lolling in lawn chairs on her small garden patio,
just a chain-link fence and a few lilac bushes away from the drone of
the LIE. Harold proudly predicted that his lawyer son Rudy would go on
one day to become president of the United States and, perhaps as
evidence, carried with him a photo of Rudy standing next to President
Ronald Reagan. He once told Lina how happy he would be if Rudy married
her beautiful daughter, Luchana.
On one of these afternoons, Harold also shared with his new
landlord his views on race. "Giuliani's father," recalled Lina, "was
disturbed by colored people." The polite woman listened as Harold
expounded on the differences between whites and blacks. "Harold say,
'God separate the colored and the white.' He say, 'Because all the
world is white, except Africa.' " Harold's explanation for why blacks
are black? "God said the colored were not mature," Lina remembered
Harold telling her. "So God put them in the oven to make them mature.
But God, he forget to take them out, so colored people came out black."
Because of his progressing prostate cancer, Harold had to
urinate frequently, and often while out in the garden with Lina, he
would stagger into a corner, unzip his pants and moan with relief as he
pissed into the weeds.
Rudy, then a full-time partner at Patterson, Belknap, earning
$160,000 per year, frequently visited his parents in Bayside and even
had his own room in their apartment. Lina remembered that the third
bedroom in Harold and Helen's apartment had been made up for Rudy, who
would occasionally stay for as long as a week at a time.
At 70 years old, Harold was commuting by bus to a part-time
custodial job at the Gotham Building Maintenance Corporation on 28th
Street in Manhattan. A man whose sporadic 50-year work history was made
up largely of off-the-books jobs was back on the books again, part of a
300-man fleet that, among other things, waxed floors, shampooed
carpets, and washed windows in city buildings.
On the weekends and on Harold's off days, he and Joe Merli
would usually walk three blocks down Horace Harding to the Bayside
Senior Citizens' Center, a flat, maroon-brick building where they would
spend the afternoon playing pool and poker with the grumbling,
ill-tempered old-timers. It was a familiar setting for Harold, its
fluorescent lighting, dull, salmon-colored linoleum floor tiles, and
bright, multicolored plastic chairs reminiscent of a high school
cafeteria. It was a place to hang out, chew the fat, get away from the
house. Everybody had chores, though, and Harold and Joe would usually
end up washing dishes. As they sponged plates one afternoon, Harold
suggested to Joe that if they only did a so-so job washing these
dishes, maybe they could escape dish duty in the future.
After more than a year living in Bayside, Harold suffered such
severe pain from his prostate cancer that he had trouble walking. He
quit Gotham Maintenance. His routine checkups at North Shore hospital
became more frequent. Lina remembered Harold telling her about his
doctor's warnings. "The doctor, he tell him, 'You have to be operated
on,' " she recalled. But when it came to surgery, the proud man was
obstinate. "Nobody is going to touch my balls!" Harold declared to Lina
one afternoon in the garden.
On some nights, racked with pain, Harold would roll out of bed
and fall onto the floor, helpless, unable to move. Helen would rush
downstairs and rouse Joe Merli, who would help hoist the stubborn,
tortured old man back into bed.
�This source, referred to subsequently as "Lewis's friend," provided
critical details of the criminal histories of Leo and Lewis D'Avanzo
and Harold Giuliani, including the fact that Harold had "done time" at
Sing Sing. Court documents and other records confirmed more than a
half-dozen pieces of information he supplied. None of his information
proved to be incorrect. A close friend of Lewis's, this source is also
a convicted felon, with a criminal record dating back to the '60s.
Time Magazine, Person of the Year profile 2001 http://www.time.com/time/poy2001/poyprofile.html
"He governed by hammering everyone else into submission, but in areas
where that strategy was ineffective, such as reform of the city
schools, he failed to make improvements. "The Boss," as his aides call
him, inspired extraordinary loyalty and repaid it. He elevated a
streetwise N.Y.P.D. detective named Bernard Kerik through the ranks of
city government, eventually making him corrections commissioner and
then police commissioner. Kerik, who compares entering Giuliani's inner
circle to becoming "a made man in a Mafia family," reduced violence by
95% in the city jails and kept crime on the decline in New York this
year even as it spiked around the country. "Nobody believed Giuliani
had a heart," Kerik says. "He's not supposed to have a heart. He's an
animal, he's obnoxious, he's arrogant. But you know what? He gets it
done. Behind getting it done, he has a tremendously huge heart, but
you're not going to succeed in New York City by being a sweetie.
Giuliani has no gray areas--good or bad, right or wrong, end of story.
That's the way he is. You don't like it, f___ you."
The
allegedly mob-tied firm at the center of the storm swirling around
ex-city police commissioner Bernard Kerik hired another former top
Giuliani aide when it wanted to show regulators it was cleaning up its
act, the Voice has learned.
Interstate Industrial Corporation hired former deputy mayor Randy
Mastro, who served as Giuliani's top gun in chasing down mobbed up
outfits doing business with the city. But Mastro said he never told his
former boss�or anyone else�about what he learned of Kerik's dealings
with the firm, including the former top cop's recommendation to the
company that it hire a close pal named Larry Ray, who was later
indicted in a mob stock fraud scam.
"Larry Ray predated my time. That had already occurred; he was gone," Mastro said. "There was no retrospective review."
Giuliani has said he knew nothing about Kerik's connection to
Interstate until the recent explosion of news reports in the wake of
Kerik's decision to withdraw as President Bush's nominee for Homeland
Security director�a post he initially won with Giuliani's enthusiastic
backing.
Mastro said he learned about Kerik's association with
Interstate during his "two or three years" with the firm as a kind of
inside watchdog, reviewing new deals and hires for any mob taint.
"At some point I was told by people at the company [about Kerik]," he said. "I don't recall exactly when."
Asked if he ever discussed the matter with Giuliani, Mastro said: "No. It wasn't an issue that I ever discussed with anyone."
Mastro's hiring came as the construction firm was desperately
battling for the right to hold city and state contracts despite
allegations of mob dealings made by several oversight
agencies�including a business integrity panel that was launched by
Mastro when he was still at City Hall.
Interstate was also facing a tough challenge by regulators of
New Jersey casinos who said the company should be barred from Atlantic
City because it had a long history of conscious involvement with
organized-crime figures.
In a controversial decision this summer, the state's Casino
Control Commission rejected the state attorney general's advice that
Interstate be denied a license for casino work. In recommending
approval for the company, the commission cited Mastro's "impressive
professional pedigree" as a onetime federal prosecutor and former
chairman of the city's Trade Waste Commission as evidence that the
company was on the straight and narrow.
The licensing decision outraged state attorney general Peter
Harvey, whose office has filed suit to block the move, saying the
approval of Interstate was "not just wrong, but dangerously wrong."
Mastro, a partner in Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, also served
under Giuliani in the Manhattan U.S. attorney's office. He said he was
brought to Interstate by their attorneys, Tom and Chauncey Durkin, and
that his job there was to scrutinize "certain high-level hiring and
major transactions" undertaken by the Clifton, New Jersey-based
company.
"I can tell you that there was never any recommendation made by this firm that wasn't followed," he said.
But Mastro said he left the company earlier this year after the
Casino Control Commission initially OK'd Interstate's application.
"There didn't seem to be any further reason for us," he said.
It was during the casino license inquiry, Mastro said, that he
learned about Kerik's company ties�and his recommendation that
Interstate hire his close friend Ray.
A former insurance and financial-services salesman, Ray was the
best man at Kerik's 1999 wedding, and even helped the apparently
cash-strapped former cop pay for the event, according to reports by the
Daily News' Russ Buettner and the Times' William K. Rashbaum and Kevin Flynn.
Kerik also went to bat for the firm with a top official of the Trade
Waste Commission, the body established by Giuliani to weed out mob-tied
carters and headed by Mastro until he left the administration in 1998.
Later that year, when Interstate was awaiting approval to operate a
waste transfer station it had purchased from mob figures, Kerik�at the
time the city's corrections chief�spoke with Raymond Casey, the
commission's top enforcement officer. According to the Times,
Kerik told Casey that his friend Ray was now working with Interstate
and that Ray was "an honest person with a security background" and
"someone we could work with."
Kerik's dealings with Interstate and Ray were later the subject of an
inquiry by the city's Department of Investigation�a probe that Giuliani
has said he was never told about even as he promoted Kerik to police
commissioner.
Interstate co-owner Frank DiTommaso has acknowledged that he
was friendly with Kerik and often visited him at his city offices, even
hiring Kerik�s brother for a job with his company. DiTommaso said he
hired Ray for a $100,000-a-year post after Kerik said he could vouch
for him. According to DiTommaso, Ray said he had "law enforcement
experience" and could help with the company's regulatory problems.
But officials of the New Jersey Attorney General's Division of
Gaming Enforcement later pointed out that Ray's prior dealings with
Interstate would hardly have inspired confidence: A recommendation Ray
made to DiTommaso concerning the company's insurance policies had
resulted in a "financial disaster" for the firm, according to the
attorney general. Just prior to his hiring by DiTommaso in 1998, Ray
had left the insurance business and had set up his own business,
"providing security to celebrities and dignitaries," according to the
casino probe.
At Interstate, however, Ray's duties were a mystery,
investigators said. "Larry Ray was employed in an undefined capacity
wherein he had no office, no phone, never generated a memo or other
writing, and had no specific hours," state gaming enforcement director
Thomas Auriemma wrote in a June letter to the state's Casino Control
Commission.
At a hearing before the panel in July, assistant attorney
general Gary Ehrlich bluntly called Ray's position "a no-show, no-work
job."
Yet Ray remained in good graces with DiTommaso and his brother
Peter, who even agreed to have the company loan him $350,000 so that
Ray could buy out a partner in a nightclub�a loan that he failed to pay
back.
But the company quickly fired Ray after he was indicted in
March 2000 in a case brought by federal prosecutors in Brooklyn.
Although the indictment focused on a securities scam orchestrated by
several high-level Mafia members, it contained eerie echoes of
Interstate's own dealings. Among the defendants was Edward Garafola, a
soldier in the Gambino family who had earlier sold the waste transfer
station to Interstate.
It was that deal with Garafola, who recently pled guilty to
both extortion and attempted murder charges in two separate federal
cases, that first brought notoriety to Interstate and led to a series
of investigations. The probes were the first stumble for a firm that
had started in a basement apartment on Staten Island and later went on
to win more than $75 million in city and state contracts, including
work on the new stadium for the Yankees affiliate on Staten Island, and
a massive project at the Fresh Kills landfill.
Ray eventually pled guilty in the stock scheme and was
sentenced to five years probation. Later, however, Ray appealed his
sentence, saying he had had faulty legal representation. In court
papers, Ray detailed his own associations with both the Mafia and
Russian organized-crime figures, and stated that he became an informant
for the FBI in 1996 after learning that Garafola had put out a
"contract" on his life. He claimed that in exchange for his help, FBI
agents promised not to prosecute him, but later reneged on the deal.
The DiTommasos have long insisted that Ray and Garafola were
both examples of the way legitimate businessmen brush up against the
mob in the construction industry. But the city's Business Integrity
Commission and the state�s Dormitory Authority have disagreed, labeling
the firm "a non-responsible contractor"�a finding that is a kiss of
death for those seeking lucrative government work.
Those rulings were underscored earlier this month when two
mobsters now cooperating with the government testified at the trial of
Gambino crime family boss Peter Gotti that Interstate made regular
payments to organized crime figures in exchange for being allowed to
pay non-union rates to workers.
Mastro declined to offer an opinion about the company's
qualifications, or Kerik's involvement. But the former deputy mayor was
one of a trio of ex-Giuliani officials, along with former fire
commissioner Tom Von Essen and ex-top City Hall aide Joseph Lhota, who
appeared on NY1 shortly after Kerik's appointment, describing their
former colleague as a stellar candidate for the Homeland Security post.
See files and photos section on these websites
To access the photo and files sections
you may have to subscribe to the groups
and have a valid email address registered with Yahoo
which you can do at http://www.yahoo.com/
Also see these sites for thousands of articles, essays, photos,
court rulings etc. on Giuliani
[BACKGROUND: As part of a Federal lawsuit, Lederman et al v
Giuliani, the former Mayor and a number of his top aides and associates were
subpoenaed on 3/1/2002 to appear for depositions. In response the Mayor's
lawyers asked the court to issue an order of protection preventing Giuliani
and his associates from having to face these depositions. Among their claims
was that there was "nothing to suggest" that Giuliani targeted Lederman or was
interested in his protest art. Giuliani had Lederman falsely arrested
more than 40 times. The depositions were held in 2003 and the City
then settled the lawsuit which was initially won by the plaintiffs in 2001.
Here are a few mainstream media quotes
on the Giuliani as Hitler paintings issue. Decide for yourself.....]
MAYOR GIULIANI ON ROBERT LEDERMAN'S GIULIANI PAINTINGS AND SIGNS
[NOTE: All the Giuliani-as-Hitler portraits and signs as well as all of the
"Arrest Giuliani"; "Impeach Giuliani"; "Giuliani = Police State"; "Fooliani"
; "Crueliani"; "Jailiani",; "Giulianus" and "Adolf Giuliani" signs referred
in these quotes to were made by Robert Lederman. In many of the newspaper
photographs accompanying these quotes, Lederman is seen carrying them or his
signature is visible on the paintings carried by other protestors. With the
exception of an arrest inside the Criminal court at #346 Broadway, all of
Robert Lederman's arrests included in Lederman et al v Giuliani specifically
involve displaying these signs and slogans while demonstrating. Hundreds of
these paintings and signs were confiscated by police officials during the
course of this lawsuit and were never returned, yet, not one case was ever
prosecuted or resulted in a plea bargain. The quotations below are a
representative sample of the many hundreds of similar ones which exist.
Aside from the newspaper quotes, the Giuliani signs appeared on U.S.
television networks many hundreds of times during Giuliani's term in office.]
Newsweek 4/5/99 Rudy on the Record
Question: "Are you personally stung by those signs at the demonstrations
that say 'Adolf Giuliani'?"
Mayor Giuliani: "Five years ago I might have cried over it. And now I just
feel that this is a crazy exaggeration that we've allowed, and that our
media coverage is selective... You cover Susan Sarandon. But [the police and
the rest of the city] see the Adolf Hitler signs, the comparisons to the
president of Yugoslavia. These [demonstrators] are getting arrested, some
knowingly, some unknowingly, under that banner."
N.Y. Daily News 10/25/1998
"I take a different view of someone comparing me to Adolf Hitler than when
someone calls me a jerk." -Mayor Giuliani
NY Times Sunday March 28, 1999 "After Meeting Mayor Vows Major Changes for
Police"
"But the Mayor repeated his anger over signs and chants at the post-Diallo
protests that liken him to Adolf Hitler. "The comparisons to Hitler, Adolf
Hitler, and fascism have to stop, because they're sick, perverted, and they
do affect some people," he said. "Invocations of Adolf Hitler are despicable
no matter who it is. Nobody should participate in it, and nobody should do
it."
NY Times 3/30/99 "Indictments of 4 Officers in the Diallo Killing Are Due
Tuesday"
"The Mayor, for his part, sought to balance his remarks on the protests by
expressing his sympathy for the Diallo family, his support for the Police
Department and his anger at the personal attacks against him. He complained
that several protesters held aloft signs that compared him to Adolf Hitler
and the Police Department to the Ku Klux Klan. "As the Police Department
has made substantial changes in the way in which it behaves, not only in the
last month or two but over the last five years," Mayor Giuliani said, "I'd
ask people to acknowledge that and then to make the similar kinds of changes
in their behavior. Not stand with people who try to pretend that the Police
Department is the KKK, not engage in general bashing of the Police
Department, stop the invocations of Hitler and Nazism and fascism, all this
exaggerated hate rhetoric. It has an impact."
4/1/99 New York Times "The Mayor: In Honoring an Officer, an Impassioned
Plea"
"In reference to the protests outside Police Headquarters in Manhattan and
the Bronx courthouse, the Mayor continued: "And it's about time to stop
carrying signs pretending that they are racist. It's about time to stop
carrying signs equating them to the K.K.K., and it's about time to stop
invocations of Adolf Hitler about our Police Department."
Daily News 4/1/99 "The Mayor Rails Vs. Cop Bashers"
"His voice choking with emotion and his fists clenched for emphasis, Mayor
Giuliani yesterday demanded "respect and understanding" for his cops in the
fiercest speech he has delivered since the killing of Amadou
Diallo...Giuliani urged protesters to lay down their "racist signs" and
begged New Yorkers to stop second-guessing the NYPD. "...And it's about time
to stop carrying signs that invoke Adolf Hitler about our police." As he
stood at the red-brick stationhouse, Giuliani attacked police "bashers" as
"the worst elements in society."
NY POST 4/16/99 -10,000 RALLY FOR 'JUSTICE'
"He also blasted the anti-cop and anti-mayor sentiment. "I think the
negative part is that many of the signs ... are highly offensive and racist
in nature ... There was a sign that had the New York Police Department
shield with a Nazi swastika superimposed over it. There were signs using
rather broadly the term racist and invocations to Hitler, to some of the
things that are going on in the Balkans ..." Giuliani complained."
NY Post 4/17/99 RUDY BLASTS DIALLO MARCHERS WHO COMPARED HIM TO HITLER
"On his weekly WABC radio show, Giuliani blasted the demonstrators who
marched across the Brooklyn Bridge carrying signs comparing him to Adolf
Hitler, and the NYPD to the Ku Klux Klan. The mayor also blasted the media
for not asking "how could people participate in a march like this, how could
people speak to a group like this, that carried signs like that?
"Unfortunately, no one is being held to account for joining in or
associating with a march that had hate signs like that," Giuliani said."
QUOTES IDENTIFYING ROBERT LEDERMAN AS THE CREATOR OF
THE GIULIANI SIGNS AND
AS A PROMINENT CRITIC OF THE MAYOR'S
NY Times 4/8/2000 Demonstrators of Old Spread Their Message in a New Era of
Protest
"Robert Lederman, 49, a street artist who has protested for years against
Mayor Giuliani's policies, often arrives with dozens of placards
caricaturing the mayor as Hitler, complete with the Fuhrer's mustache".
Daily News 10/3/99 Courts Thwart Hizzoner's Tactics
"I guess the mayor doesn't like the paintings I do of him as Adolf Hitler,"
said Lederman, whose mustachioed portrayals of the mayor pop up regularly at
rallies critical of the city."
Village Voice 3/28/2000
Why Safir Must Resign by former NYPD detective, Frank Serpico
"An example of this harassment is the arrest not once but more than 40 times
of street artist Robert Lederman, merely for expressing his First Amendment
rights. Giuliani did not like the artists' caricature of him as Adolf
Hitler. All charges against him were subsequently dismissed."
NY Post 8/11/2001 COURT: PERMIT ART WITHOUT PERMIT
"Since the troubles erupted with Giuliani, some of Lederman's work, using
acrylic and cardboard, has reflected his disdain for the mayor. There are
postcards and paintings featuring Hizzoner as a ghoulish-looking Hitler with
captions such as "Adolf Jailiani," "Zero Tolerance for Arts" and "It's
disgusting - Giuli-anus."
Jewish Week 5/7/99 His Artwork Raises A Fuehrer
"In a vastly unpopular view even among some of the mayor's staunchest public
critics, Lederman insists the Hitler comparison is not hyperbolic...The
signs, which Lederman distributed to the protestors, were panned by Jewish
leaders."
Newsday 10/5/99 'Sensation' Show Is Rank With Smut and Cruelty
"Then there's Robert Lederman, who has art of his own. Enraged by New York
Mayor Rudy Giuliani's decision to suspend city funding for the museum, he
holds aloft two signs: "Giuli-anus" features a caricature of the mayor with
a piece of plastic novelty poop glued to his forehead; "Fooliani" depicts
him as a one-man insane clown posse."
NY Newsday 3/30/2001 City's Gatekeepers of Decency? Rudy supporters may
police tax-funded museums
"Robert Lederman, a Manhattan man who began sketching political art of the
mayor with a Hitler mustache after the city's 1995 arrests of sidewalk art
vendors, called the art panel "ludicrous." "If it wasn't so ludicrous, it
would be just comical-but unfortunately we've known from watching Giuliani
for nearly eight years that he's not kidding," Lederman said."
5/9/98 Washington Post
"An exhibit of the mayor's photographs opened today at a downtown Manhattan
gallery, displaying 23 of his color and black-and-white pictures taken over
the last two years. Panning the exhibit altogether were the sidewalk
protesters, who are fighting a city requirement that they need permits to
sell artwork in parks and in front of the Metropolitan Museum of Art. "Since
his first day in office, Giuliani has been waging a war on artists and
artists' rights," said painter and printmaker Robert Lederman. "He's doing
this show purely to change his image, posing as an artist in the arts
capital of the world."
Capitol Police, 0 Speech Activist, 2 Washington Post 3/20/2000
"Lederman's quarrel with Capitol Police was fairly mild compared with his
ongoing spat with New York Mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani (R). He fought Giuliani
in the courts over the right of artists to sell their works on the streets
without a license. He won that battle, but his criticism of Giuliani hasn't
stopped, and Lederman frequently has been arrested at protests of the
mayor's policies. He has painted portraits that depict Giuliani as Hitler or
Satan."
Washington Post 6/4/98 "Mayor's on a Roll Vendors Aren't Buying"
"At today's rally, which attracted about 400 vendors, street artists, and a
smattering of taxi drivers, the mayor was described as: "Crueliani,"
"Jailiani," and "Stalag Gholiani". Many of the protesting street artists
have had their artwork confiscated this year by police after they displayed
it without a permit in front of the Metropolitan Museum of Art on Fifth
Avenue. Lederman said police have confiscated his paintings of the mayor on
more than 30 occasions. He said there is one that particularly attracts the
confiscatory enthusiasm of the cops: "It says 'Giuliani Equals Police
State."
NY Times June 26, 1998-Mayor Abandons Plan to Ban Sidewalk Vendors
"The rules for food vendors will also affect street artists. Robert
Lederman, a leader of the artists who has called for Mr. Giuliani's
impreachment, said he was alarmed by all of the solutions being considered
by the Council. Each, he asserted, would lead to the replacement of today's
vendors with well-financed companies that could afford to buy the newly
rationed right to sell on the sidewalk. "For the past 100 years, vendors
have been poor immigrants who were struggling to establish themselves", Mr.
Lederman said. "Anybody could get their start on the street. Now we're
headed toward the privitization of public space".
NY Times 7/9/98 Metro Matters: Charter Panel, Adding Insult to Revision?
"Robert Lederman, by his own account SoHo's most frequently arrested street
artist, said: "I would like to offer my condolences to this distinguished
panel. You do a great deal of damage to your own reputations by
participating in it...Eleven of Mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani's 12 appointees
had shown up for the hearing and they sat through it all impassively, never
posing a single question, never challenging a single statement and, at least
as far as this columnist could discern, never taking a single note. "
Newsday, 10/10/99 Bugged by Spraying
"The loudest protests heard during the city's recent campaign of insecticide
spraying came from the city's tiny Green Party and the artist-agitator
Robert Lederman."
From: http://www.thefire.org/offsite/abc_061201.html
TRANSCRIPT ABC NEWS 3/23/2000
Free Speech In America hosted by John Stossel [a video of the one hour
show is also available. The Giuliani portraits and this interview opened the
show.]
"1ST MAN Giuliani is a danger to America.
2ND MAN He's trying to tamper with the American constitution.
JOHN STOSSEL (VO) Giuliani wouldn't talk to us about this. But, to give the
mayor his due, the city is in great shape today. Crime's been cut in half.
And the streets, where fewer people are screaming at us, are more pleasant.
Most people like what Giuliani did. But some, like Robert Lederman, suggest
it's not worth the cost.
ROBERT LEDERMAN Real quality of life is not about not being bothered. It's
about civil liberties. It's about freedom of speech.
JOHN STOSSEL (VO) Lederman's a street artist who sells these pictures
portraying Giuliani as Hitler, making New York into a police state. For
doing this, says Lederman, he's been arrested dozens of times.
ROBERT LEDERMAN You're arresting me for what, exactly?
3RD MAN Blocking the sidewalk.
JOHN STOSSEL (VO) Officials say he was arrested for things like disorderly
conduct, not for his artwork. But Lederman claims the cops told him it was
because of his speech.
ROBERT LEDERMAN While they're putting the handcuffs on me, they're saying,
'Hey, you know, we're really sorry, Rob, but we know you didn't do anything
illegal, but that's our orders.'
JOHN STOSSEL (VO) Police wouldn't even comment on that. Now, Giuliani
attributes much of the improvement in quality of life in New York to his
enforcing laws, which had long been ignored. Laws against vagrancy,
aggressive panhandling, against the squeegee men who wash your car windows,
whether you want them washed or not. Lederman and others argue that those
activities are forms of free speech, too. So, Giuliani had no right to
curtail them, either. You know, people are happy that people aren't stopping
us on the streets, saying, 'Spare change? Spare change?' We like that. And
you're kind of like that. You're spreading your stuff around you.
ROBERT LEDERMAN Actually, I'm taking up about two inches of the sidewalk on
my own car. But to answer what you're saying...
JOHN STOSSEL People like what Giuliani did.
ROBERT LEDERMAN People like what Hitler did. Does that make it right?
The only reason I'm being arrested is because of the content of my message.
JOHN STOSSEL (VO) The danger is that, if government decides when people may
speak, that could lead to tyranny.
ROBERT LEDERMAN If you're going to criticize elected officials, you need
freedom of speech. Because they command the police, they influence the
courts. They're in a position to stop you from criticizing them."
NY POST EDITORIALS AND OP-EDS ON ROBERT LEDERMAN'S GIULIANI PAINTINGS AND
SIGNS
Demonizing Rudy Giuliani NY Post Editorial 6/16/98
"We'll say it simply: Just because people don't like Rudy Giuliani doesn't
give them license to compare him to Adolf Hitler. The Hitler analogy is
something that seems to amuse many people in this city. Cutesy stories have
been written and published in the past week about an art installation on
Madison Avenue called No York in which the mayor is depicted with a Hitler
moustache. This image was first bandied about by an obnoxious twerp who
claims to represent a group called A.R.T.I.S.T. - but which really ought to
be called M.O.R.O.N. - who is outraged that the mayor attempted to enforce
plainly written statutes regarding sidewalk clutter in front of the
Metropolitan Museum. For this, the twerp (whose name we shall never again
use because he deserves no more public mention) imagines that Rudy Giuliani
deserves comparison with the personification of evil in this century...As
the New York Times' gleeful seizure of the "bunker" story indicates, you
don't have to be a cabbie, a vendor or a M.O.R.O.N. to issue forth such
repulsive opinions."
N.Y. Post 8/20/98 EDITORIAL FREE SPEECH - OR FREE EXHIBITION SPACE?
"Thanks to Mayor Giuliani's quality-of-life program, New Yorkers no longer
have to step over quite so many vagrants in order to enjoy the greenery of
New York's parks or the aesthetic stimulation of the Metropolitan Museum of
Art. Unfortunately, thanks to Manhattan Criminal Court Judge Lucy Billings,
they might now find themselves navigating their way around hordes of
self-described "artists" who think it's appropriate to liken politicians
they oppose to Hitler."
NY POST editorial 5/17/98 THE ARTIST HUSTLE
"The so-called artists who have been demonstrating outside the Metropolitan
Museum of Art believe that their daubings and scratchings should be treated
in the same way books are. Fair enough. But they also want an unlimited
right to sell their product outside the Metropolitan Museum of Art, on a
plaza that belongs to the Parks Department. The Artist Vendor Permit system,
which, incidently, was suggested by the ACLU, has been going since 1995.
Every month 85 percent of applicants get a license, and both congestion and
scuffles between rival artist-vendors are avoided. But when the Parks
Department extended this reasonable system to the Metropolitan plaza earlier
this year, a bunch of artist-activists who call themselves "Artists'
Response to Illegal State Tactics" (yes, the acronym is ARTIST) went beserk.
They held noisy demonstrations, displayed drawings of the mayor as Adolf
Hitler, and made other ludicrous and offensive comparisons - including
likening themselves to the democracy protesters in Tiananmen Square. Then
they defied the permit system and were accordingly arrested".
NY Post Editorial 3/20/99 THE GIULIANI PILE-ON
"That, of course, is why Sharpton & Co. are marching against the mayor and
don't even mention Bronx DA Robert Johnson, who is in charge of the
investigation and whose grand jury is hearing the evidence. That's why the
signs carried by those same demonstrators don't refer to Diallo but instead
outrageously compare the mayor to Adolf Hitler and call for his arrest."
NY Post 3/31/99
THEY'RE AFTER RUDY, NOT JUSTICE By JOHN PODHORETZ
"And there's nothing a member of the liberal Establishment hates as much as
a conservative anti-Establishmentarian. That's why he so enrages his foes,
to the point that they happily march alongside caricatures depicting him as
Hitler. That's why, in the interest of discrediting him, they are willing to
make common cause with Al Sharpton, whom they would ordinarily revile."
NY Post 3/31/99 AL'S 'CIVIL-RIGHTS COALITION': A TRAVESTY OF DR. KING'S
DREAM
"In effect, King practiced the philosophy of personal suffering and of love.
I dare say that he would have denounced those bigoted signs and banners
equating the NYPD with the KKK, and depicting the mayor as ''Adolf
Giuliani.'' Did the Rev. Sharpton protest those signs? Did any of the Jewish
leaders or other white liberals who stood with him to rightly decry police
brutality also demand that those carrying such calumny not be allowed to
distract from a message of reconciliation?"
NEWSPAPER QUOTES ON MAYOR GIULIANI 'TARGETING' OPPONENTS
"It is not a good idea to be on the wrong side of Giuliani. You are better
off negotiating a solution than being a warrior." Giuliani's PR consultant
Howard Rubinstein quoted in NY Times 9/30/99 Master Image Spinner at the
Center of a Web
NY Times 10/10/99 Common Perception: The Mayor Will Get You for That
"The Mayor tends to take those who disagree with him as enemies to be
punished," Martin McLaughlin, a lobbyist for the cultural institutions,
wrote in an E-mail circulated among museum directors...Yet many people whose
livelihoods depend on City Hall say they are growing weary of the Mayor's
get-even act... These grumblers, who, out of fear, demand anonymity, include
builders, directors of nonprofit agencies and business leaders of nearly
every stripe. "Intimidation is his full-time operating style," said a
prominent businessman who says he likes the Mayor and raises money for him,
but is afraid to be even mildly critical of him in public. .."It was
instant, naked retaliation," said a state official familiar with the
project. "Without question, it is the way City Hall works. In the case of
the city's cultural institutions, many of which are in city-owned buildings
or depend on city money for daily operations, several museum directors said
privately that they took so long to criticize the Mayor because they were
afraid he would punish them. "You can feel the fear and intimidation that is
out there because this is an administration that engages in retribution
constantly," said Councilman Stephen DiBrienza, a Brooklyn Democrat who last
year sponsored a homeless shelter bill that the Mayor did not like. Some of
the Mayor's most ardent supporters, business leaders who say that his
achievements in reducing crime and cleaning up the city are historically
significant, are often just as afraid of him as his harshest critics...One
businessman said developers were afraid to speak ill of the Mayor, even
privately, for fear that word would get back to him. Similarly, the director
of a private nonprofit agency that depends on the city said that she and
dozens of her peers have concluded that the only way to protect the poor
people they serve is never to say anything in public that the Mayor might
not like."
NY Times 3/23/2002
Taxi Drivers Win a First Amendment Round Against the City
By ROBERT F. WORTH
"A federal judge ruled yesterday that city officials violated the First
Amendment nearly four years ago when they blocked a demonstration in which
taxi drivers planned to flood the Queensboro Bridge and Broadway with their
cars during the morning rush hour. The ruling, by Judge William H. Pauley
III of United States District Court in Manhattan, stated that the city's
decision to disrupt the planned demonstration, on May 21, 1998, was
motivated by retaliation for a one-day strike the taxi drivers had organized
earlier that month, and not by concerns about traffic and safety, as the
city's lawyers claimed."
QUOTES ON GIULIANI ABUSING THE LEGAL SYSTEM TO 'TARGET' OPPONENTS
Daily News 10/14/99 City Lawyers Let Public Down
"The Giuliani administration has plunged into one legal morass after
another. Courts have ruled against the city in its campaigns against street
artists, demonstrators at City Hall, taxi drivers staging protests, marchers
in Harlem and advertisers on buses...Even more troubling than this pattern
of skirting and breaking the law is the apparent lack of concern about it in
city government. City officials often respond to other branches of
government - or members of the public who voice disagreement - with ad
hominem attacks that convey a basic contempt for our system of government.
Judges who rule against the city can expect scathing name-calling, like the
invective the mayor heaped on the judges who heard the Million Youth March
case. Private groups that have disputes with the city are, in effect, placed
on an enemies list. This attitude sends a message that rules are made to be
broken - or at least manipulated beyond recognition. Opponents are to be
destroyed, not simply defeated."
Associated Press December 2, 1999
NYC Mayor Hot Topic at Law Schools
NEW YORK (AP) -- Move over, Thomas Jefferson.
The hottest topic at some law schools these days is New York City's Mayor,
Rudolph Giuliani, who's been sued two dozen times on First Amendment grounds
and lost nearly every case. ``Lately it seems as if I could teach a First
Amendment course just on Mayor Giuliani,'' mused Amy Adler, a professor at
New York University School of Law. Professors say their favorite cases
include Giuliani's attempt to cut the Brooklyn Museum of Art's funding after
it displayed a painting of the Virgin Mary decorated with elephant dung.
There's also the mayor's attempt to stop New York magazine from buying ad
space on city buses following its campaign poking fun at him, and the
mayor's efforts to deny permits for demonstrations by groups ranging from
taxi drivers to the Ku Klux Klan. ``It's important in any area of the law to
try to show students that what they're learning is relevant,'' said Michael
Dorff, a Columbia Law School professor. ``The beauty of living in New York
is that the mayor is constantly generating classroom hypotheticals.'' ``He's
like an archetype of the figure that the First Amendment was kind of aimed
at protecting us from -- the government official out of control,'' said
Bruce Miller, a professor at Western New England College of Law in
Springfield, Mass...Jeffrey M. Shaman, a professor at DePaul University
College of Law in Chicago, says he uses the Giuliani cases ``to talk about
the idea that offensiveness of speech is not a reason to restrict it. And we
use it to talk about the tendency of some governmental officials to
overreach their authority and try to regulate speech they don't like.''
Norman Siegel, the director of the New York Civil Liberties Union and party
to many anti-Giuliani lawsuits, has a more blunt assessment. "The reason why
I think professors are teaching Giuliani 101, in effect, is that this is a
clear example of government abuse of authority,'' he said."
NY Times May 23, 1999
The Giuliani Way: Sue and Be Sued, and Sometimes Win by Losing
by BRUCE LAMBERT, New York Times
"Most people dread going to court, but not Mayor Rudolph W. Giuliani. He has
repeatedly demonstrated during his five years at City Hall that he loves a
legal battle. The Mayor has sued people ranging from street artists to
President Clinton, to cite two cases he appealed all the way to the United
States Supreme Court. He won the suit against the President but lost his
case against the artists. More often than not, Giuliani loses. Why, then,
does he sue -- and get sued -- so often? Both supporters and critics cite
several reasons, including his contentious style, reluctance to compromise
on his policies, and his prior career as a prosecutor....Giuliani not only
files lawsuits, but critics say he also provokes suits against his
administration by refusing to reach compromises, or by withholding
information that previous mayors made available as a matter of course...When
the Mayor fails to get his way, he often voices contempt for the courts.
Ordered to permit a march against police brutality, he scoffed at "the
imperial Federal court" and said judges "think they're put here by God." He
has scorned rulings as "idiotic," "not honest" and "the product of the
Democratic machine." Some accuse Giuliani of trying to intimidate the
judiciary. In 1997, the City Bar Association's president, Michael A.
Cardozo, warned against attempts "to bully the courts."...Giuliani has
altered the Corporation Counsel's traditional semiautonomy, critics say. In
the past, the counsel advised top city officials and helped settle disputes.
Now, critics say, Giuliani acts as his own counsel and uses that office
against other officials...Giuliani often says, "I was a practicing lawyer
for a lot longer than I was Mayor." In deciding the car-seizure policy, he
said, "I spent two hours reading law books and statutes myself -- my real
profession is being a lawyer." The Corporation Counsel under Dinkins, Victor
A. Kovner, said of Giuliani: "Unlike his predecessors, this is a man who
still thinks he is a practicing lawyer. But it's the courts who decide what
the law is, not the Mayor." The critics say that Giuliani often forces
litigation even when he has little chance of winning. "They use the courts
with enormous frequency, not so much to test legal issues, but as a weapon,"
said Eric Lane, the director of the 1989 City Charter commission and a law
professor at Hofstra. Public Advocate Mark Green, who had to sue to get
police brutality records, said: "The City's poor win-loss record results
from a client who insists on bringing losing cases because he wants to
exhaust, stall or intimidate critics. Even when he loses legally, he may
have so delayed the march or investigation that he wins tactically."
NYPD SPOKESPERSON MARILYN MODE ON GIULIANI 'TARGETING' ROBERT LEDERMAN
Jewish Week 5/7/99
"Police department spokeswoman Marilyn Mode called that claim [that I was
targeted] "delusional. He has been given summonses several times for
disorderly conduct. It's pathetic that he's so intent on trying to attract
attention to himself."
CORPORATION COUNSEL ROBIN BINDER ON GIULIANI 'TARGETING' ROBERT LEDERMAN
"Robert Lederman, who frequently depicted Mayor Giuliani in a Hitler
caricature, believes that the law enforcement action taken against him was
subjectively motivated by malice on the part of the Giuliani
administration...nor can plaintiffs provide any evidence tending to suggest
that the enforcement actions taken against Lederman were the result of a
mayoral directive of any sort. Plaintiffs cannot use the discovery process
to harass Mayor Giuliani and other members of his administration simply
because Robert Lederman claims, without support, that there was some sort of
vendetta against him."
NY Times
Kerik Contact Is Said to Lead to Demotion of Jail Official
By WILLIAM K. RASHBAUM
Published: April 14, 2006
The chief spokesman for the Department of Correction was demoted this
week after the agency learned that he had been recorded talking to his
friend and former boss, Bernard B. Kerik, about a continuing city
inquiry in defiance of direct orders, according to two people who were
briefed on the matter.
The discussions between Mr. Kerik and the spokesman, Thomas Antenen,
were recorded by prosecutors who tapped Mr. Kerik's cellphone for two
months last summer, according to the people who were briefed. They were
granted anonymity because that investigation is still open.
Mr. Antenen, 57, was asked to step down from his deputy commissioner's
position at the request of Correction Commissioner Martin F. Horn,
according to a one-sentence statement released yesterday.
Mr. Antenen was formally transferred from that appointive
$131,318-a-year job on Wednesday, an official said. He remains an
employee of the department because he still holds a much lower civil
service rank. His salary was cut by more than half, to roughly $55,000,
the people said.
The department is considering administrative charges because of his actions.
Mr. Antenen, who did not return a phone message left at his home
yesterday, has close to 20 years of city service and was one of the
longest-serving spokesmen in city government. He was a deputy
commissioner at both the Correction and Police Departments under Mr.
Kerik, the former police commissioner who withdrew as a nominee for
federal homeland security secretary in late 2004.
The court-ordered wiretap of Mr. Kerik's cellphone was part of a
criminal investigation by city investigators and prosecutors into
payment of several hundred thousand dollars' worth of renovations to
Mr. Kerik's Bronx apartment six years ago, people knowledgeable about
that case have said.
According to the people who were briefed, Mr. Antenen was questioned in
a separate but related inquiry by city investigators into other
accusations of misconduct that came to light after Mr. Kerik withdrew
his nomination, including questions about an apartment near ground zero
that he was said to have used for extramarital affairs.
Mr. Antenen was specifically ordered by Department of Investigation
lawyers not to discuss his interview with anyone, the people said.
The substance of the conversations was provided to Correction
Department officials in recent days, and Mr. Antenen was questioned
about the matter on Monday, one of the people said.
One matter that Mr. Antenen discussed with Mr. Kerik was a correction
officer, Jeannette Pinero, with whom Mr. Kerik has admitted having an
affair, both people said. Mr. Antenen appeared to be serving as in
intermediary between Mr. Kerik and Ms. Pinero, who could not talk to
Mr. Kerik because of the inquiry, the people said.
Mr. Antenen's ability to survive in appointive political posts through
several mayoral administrations has been viewed by many in government
as a mark of both his professional skills and artful diplomacy.
Michael Jacobson, the director of the Vera Institute of Justice, a
nonprofit policy research organization, and Mr. Kerik's predecessor at
the Department of Correction, praised Mr. Antenen as a committed civil
servant. "I found him incredibly professional and good at his job," Mr.
Jacobson said. "He was a tremendous help to me when I was there."
Mr. Antenen is not the first casualty of the investigation into Mr.
Kerik by prosecutors from the office of the Bronx district attorney,
Robert T. Johnson, and lawyers from the city Department of
Investigation, who have recently concluded a two-month presentation to
a grand jury.
At the end of last month, Michael Caruso, the longtime inspector
general at the Department of Correction, was asked to leave his post
because, in the words of one person knowledgeable about his departure,
"he was too close to Kerik."
Mr. Caruso, whose job was to root out corruption at all levels of the
agency, attended Mr. Kerik's wedding reception in 1998. And Mr. Caruso
helped prepare Mr. Kerik for his August 2000 interview with Mayor
Rudolph W. Giuliani for the job of police commissioner, according to
Mr. Kerik's account in his autobiography, "'The Lost Son."
Days later, Mr. Caruso was among the close friends who spent the
evening with Mr. Kerik as he awaited Mr. Giuliani's telephone call to
tell him if he had gotten the job. Mr. Giuliani appointed him police
commissioner the next day.
The person knowledgeable about his departure said that Mr. Caruso was
offered other city inspector general's posts — at the Parks and
Sanitation Departments — - but declined to take them, and was then
forced out.
He could not be reached for comment last night.
* Times Select Content Kerik Is Accused Of Abusing Post As City Official (November 16, 2005)
Comment on Giuliani says world economy can survive attack [see article below]
From Giuliani's perspective 9/11 was a giant economic engine that
launched him and various fake security companies he now helps run into
the stratoshere. He went from earning less than $200,000 a year to
getting paid $100,000 for each ten minute speech about his alleged
greatness. His staff members became millionaires as well. After failing
to protect the City and then participating in the 9/11 coverup they all
became top security consultants. What the media that has since lionized
Giuliani never mentions about this hero of 9/11 is that Giuliani was
the only witness at the 9/11 hearings booed by the family members of
those who died in the WTC. He actually had to end his testimomy because
they went nuts about the lies he was telling and accused him of being
responsible for many of the deaths.
The Associated Press/SEOUL, South Korea
By KELLY OLSEN
AP Business Writer
Giuliani: World economy can survive attack
APR. 12 6:59 A.M. ET Former New York Mayor Rudolph Giuliani said
Wednesday that another Sept. 11-like terror attack would be disastrous
but he was confident the world economy could withstand it.
"New York survived Sept. 11, America survived Sept. 11, the world did,"
Giuliani told reporters. "It's not something that you hope happens but
if it did, I would think America, New York, the world economy would
survive that also. We're much stronger than we think we are."
Giuliani made the comments on the sidelines of an international
financial conference he attended in South Korea's capital organized by
the Financial Times newspaper.
In the attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, hijackers slammed jetliners into the
World Trade Center in New York and the Pentagon in Washington. A fourth
hijacked jet crashed into a Pennsylvania field. In all, nearly 3,000
people died.
"If it were to happen again, it would be catastrophic," Giuliani said.
"Just given the fact that you learn from prior things that happen it
probably would be handled better, if you can handle something like that
better. The impact of it is just beyond anyone."
Giuliani, who served as major of New York from 1994 to the end of 2001,
was lauded for his supervision of the emergency response to the attacks.
Regarding the slow pace of redevelopment of the former site of the twin
towers -- hung up on commercial and insurance disputes as well as
arguments over how best to honor the victims -- Giuliani cautioned that
time is required for a consensus to emerge.
"It would obviously be better if it moved faster but in a way it's
almost inevitable that it will take a long time because ... there's a
great deal of division emotionally about what should be there," he said.
Giuliani now heads his own company, Giuliani Partners LLP, which
focuses on emergency preparedness, public safety and corporate
governance.
Regarding a possible presidential run, the Republican said it's still too early to consider such an option.
"I'll probably give it real consideration about a year from now and
that would be about the time that you'd want to think about it really
seriously other than just as a long-term thing, and then make a
decision," Giuliani said.
Newsday
9/11 widows rap Rudy's testimony
BY JOHN RILEY
Newsday Staff Writer
April 9, 2006
Rudy Giuliani's "hero of 9/11" star turn as the leadoff witness last
week in the punishment phase of Zacarias Moussaoui's death penalty
trial did not sit well with some Sept. 11 widows who think the
ex-mayor's bad judgment cost lives that day.
"I don't understand why he was invited to give a victim impact
statement," said Kristen Breitweiser, who lost her husband and was part
of the core group of 9/11 advocates that lobbied for creation of the
Sept. 11 Commission. "Why Mayor Giuliani? I don't think he needs
closure, and he didn't lose loved ones. I think his judgments caused
loved ones to be lost."
Breitweiser and other victims' families have long criticized the
Giuliani administration for equipping firefighters with dysfunctional
radios that kept them from hearing evacuation orders on Sept. 11, and
for locating the city's emergency command center in the World Trade
Center complex, a known terrorist target. The command center was
paralyzed on Sept. 11, adding to the city's chaotic response.
Although Giuliani wasn't a victim, the vast disruptions and economic
losses in New York City are included along with the impact on victims'
families in the long list of "aggravating factors" federal prosecutors
have asserted justify the death penalty for Moussaoui. But the ex-mayor
got a lot of latitude and deference in his testimony Monday.
He didn't just quantify disruptions. He shared with jurors the
emotional impact of seeing people holding hands jump from the upper
reaches of the towers, and described friends he had lost that day,
repeating the dramatic Sept. 11 narrative that made his book
"Leadership" a big seller and Giuliani himself a much sought-after
speaker, security-consulting entrepreneur and Republican political
force.
"I wanted to vomit," said Monica Gabrielle, another Sept. 11 widow, of
Giuliani's appearance. "He spent 3 1/2 hours talking about the horror
of the day, but he didn't mention the things he failed to do. This is
the same story he's been out giving speeches and getting paid for, for
four years. He should be apologizing instead of getting fees."
A Giuliani spokeswoman did not return calls for comment last week.
The criticism runs deeper than Giuliani's appearance at the trial last
week. Breitweiser, who first offered her caustic commentary in a blog
on "The Huffington Post" Web site, said the former mayor opposed
creation of the Sept. 11 Commission. Later, when he testified before
the commission about New York City's disaster response, he argued that
blame should be focused on terrorists and not government failures.
That same tension surrounds the Moussaoui trial. While prosecutors have
spent 4 1/2 years trying to execute Moussaoui, critics like Breitweiser
and Gabrielle wish the government - and leaders like Giuliani - would
show equal commitment and accountability for improving areas such as
emergency communication systems and port security that could put the
country at risk again.
"The whole thing is like a circus," said Gabrielle. "There are more proactive things to be done."
'Giuliani Time' Exposes the Real Face of "America's Mayor"
Explosive Documentary to Be Released as the 2008 Presidential Race Heats Up
With May 12 Premiere in New York
LOS ANGELES – Rudy Giuliani, former New York City Mayor, is the "hottest" politician in the country, according to a recent Quinnipiac poll. Director Kevin Keating's shocking documentary, "Giuliani Time," will premiere in New York at the Landmark Sunshine Cinema on May 12, 2006, and widen thereafter, following successful runs at the Rotterdam, Sydney, New Zealand, and Vancouver International Film Festivals. Cinema Libre Studio has acquired worldwide rights and will be releasing the title on DVD in September 2006.
Utilizing a range of personalities and experts from high-level city officials to community activists, lawyers and politicians, Keating's film analyzes TIME Magazine's 2001, "Person of the Year," his family history, his disastrous record on the First Amendment, his use and abuse of government powers and the severe methods he employed to enforce the Quality of Life and ZeroTolerance campaigns in NYC.
The film's carefully developed revelations in "Giuliani Time" contrast sharply with the image portrayed by the Draft Rudy Giuliani for President Campaign (www.draftrudy.com) as the man "who held the city of New York together and helped strengthen America's resolve," as well as the mayor who "returned accountability to city government and improved the quality of life for all New Yorkers. Under Mr. Giuliani's leadership, New York City became the best-known example of the resurgence of urban America."
Wayne Barrett, Senior Editor of the Village Voice, featured in the film, says "It's in the bloodstream of New Yorkers…. And apparently, it is now even in the bloodstream of Americans, this mythology that Rudy Giuliani single handedly…superhero…conquered crime in New York City.""Giuliani Time" contributes significantly to the historical record by disclosing disturbing facts about his history that conscientious voters from across the political spectrum should take into consideration.
The film began when a prominent constitutional lawyer approached Keating's company, K Video Productions, concerned about Giuliani's restrictions on free speech and his fractious relationship with the media. "The project started as a short film to explore the dynamics and tensions in issues around the First Amendment," says Keating. "But as would be the case repeatedly over the following years, dramatic events unfolded around us, necessitating the need to render a comprehensive document of the time." "Giuliani Time" took 5 years to complete. It's a wild ride of political ambition and amnesia, alternate realities, wars of perception and dramatic, even cataclysmic, events.
Cinema Libre Studio, the independent studio known for distributing socially conscious titles, will handle distribution."It is crucial that Americans are given access to as much factual information about their political leaders as possible in order to vote intelligently," says Richard Castro, Head of Theatrical Distribution at Cinema Libre Studio."This film reveals a side of Rudolph Giuliani that most of us have been unaware of or afraid to publicly address."
The film will open in New York at the Landmark Sunshine Cinema on May 12 and play in select theatres across the country.
Cinema Libre Studio is a haven for independent filmmakers with views, offering one-stop shopping for production, co-production, distribution, marketing, and post-production services. Headquartered in Los Angeles, the company is best known for distributing in theaters and on DVD titles that include "Outfoxed," "Uncovered," "Drowned Out," Tim Robbin's "Embedded Live," "POPaganda" and "Through the Fire."Several Cinema Libre Studio productions are currently in festivals, including "Conventioneers," nominated for the 2006 Independent Spirit `John Cassavetes' award, and "The Empire in Africa," winner for Best Documentary at Slamdance 2006. For more information visit www.cinemalibrestudio.com.
EDITORS AND PRODUCERS: If you are interested in receiving a screener or to schedule an interview with director Kevin Keating, please contact Mary Keeler at mkeeler@... or call 818-349-8822.
Hello all and welcome to the Giuliani Time Yahoo group. If anyone has
any suggestions as to the content or layout of this group please let me
know asap so that I can make changes.
Also, we need to promote this group as much as possible so please feel
free to send invitations to all your contact lists. In addition, for
anyone with a webpage, there is also a way to set up a direct link on
your page. Just click on Promote in the options menu and you will be
provided with the html code.
Thank you,
Pauline Abrams