Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
friends_and_fugitives · Planet of the Apes Tv Series
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Real people. Real stories. See how Yahoo! Groups impacts members worldwide.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
To Laura Price:'The Fourth Fugitive'.   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #8212 of 8430 |
Hi Laura Price

Just would like to comment on your fan fiction `The Fourth Fugitive'.

I must say that I was not really impressed with it; the first half
seemed promising, then you had to ruin it with sexual references and
romance. It was a really turn-off, and wasn't really necessary (the
sexual reference, B___ J___, please consider the readership when
constructing a story, you don't know who will be reading it).

There wasn't really a story with that much imagination, (good but...)
I was disappointed. Having said that, I have read a lot of fan
fiction and only a few I would deem excellent, while the rest were
quite good in the imagination department, while only two that I
really dislike and one was really boring.

Yours is on the whole quite good but it needs more work on it, I
don't know how long you've worked on it, but to me it seemed rushed
with no real thought put in.

Now there are two points I would like to point out within your story,
first when Kate stated that she left earth in 2010. This of course
was impossible since the nuclear war happened in 2006, so it is
assumed that ANSA/NASA could not launch any ships as Cape Kennedy
would be targeted by perhaps non-nuclear missiles for obvious
reasons. So Laura your timeline is wrong on that point; secondly, and
this can be debated you mentioned Jones first name as Jack, which is
your choice, but if you had bothered to look at my `Character Bio's'
and my `POTA Timeline' which is in the files section, you would
realise that Jones first name is Stephen.

Now I don't want to toot my own horn here, but there is one general
problem, it seems to me that in order for POTA's fan fiction to be
credible within the ape mythos, there must be-in this case `Writer
Information' about the main characters in the POTA TV series. This
end I have tried to put together the `Character Bio's' and the `POTA
Timeline for all to use so that future fan fiction can be uniformed
as far as information is concerned.

It's nice to write about Virdon, Burke and Galen and their adventures
but if we as fan fiction writers don't stick to certain facts then
the whole story becomes useless. One case in point is that I read a
story where Burke had 3 older brothers, but as you know, in actual
fact, he has only 2 sisters; either the author didn't know this or
totally disregarded this information.

So al in all what I'm trying to say is that there must be information
available about the characters so there won't be any stuff-ups.

Thence my contribution of `Character Bio's' and my Timeline.

There must be uniformity in POTA fan fiction writing, if we are to
make the world of POTA's real to the fans.

If we don't imagination not withstanding, then how can we make POTA's
credible in it's readership?

Regards.

Peter.






Tue Aug 19, 2008 1:42 am

peter_karsten63
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #8212 of 8430 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

Hi Laura Price Just would like to comment on your fan fiction `The Fourth Fugitive'. I must say that I was not really impressed with it; the first half seemed...
peter_karsten63
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2008
1:42 am

In a message dated 8/18/08 8:42:32 PM Central Daylight Time, peter_karsten63@... writes: There must be uniformity in POTA fan fiction writing if we...
mlccougar@...
mlccougar
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2008
3:39 am

In a message dated 8/18/08 8:42:32 PM Central Daylight Time, peter_karsten63@... writes: Now I don't want to toot my own horn here, but there is one...
mlccougar@...
mlccougar
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2008
3:53 am

Hi Peter, I haven't commented to the group for a while (have mainly shifted my attention over to Supernatural fandom), but I've been keeping up with posts and...
fanficwriter1966
fanficwriter...
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2008
1:54 pm

I'd add to Carol's comment that it's not always the intent of the writer to stay with canon or the facts as someone else may perceive them. In my experience,...
V
valwp
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2008
4:25 pm

I read the comments, too, and had to sit back and think a bit. A lot of people who write fanfic tend to write AU (alternate universe) where they make some...
Venkie
venkmeister
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2008
5:16 pm

In a message dated 8/19/08 12:16:58 PM Central Daylight Time, venkie@... writes: I think it was George Lucas who said canon was what was on the screen,...
mlccougar@...
mlccougar
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2008
6:21 pm

In a message dated 8/19/08 8:54:31 AM Central Daylight Time, fanficwriter1966@... writes: As for there needing to be "uniformity" in all fanfic - I...
mlccougar@...
mlccougar
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2008
6:34 pm

There's an established tradition in fanfic (throughout various fandoms) regarding situations like that: "What if Galen was adopted by a family of Orangutans...
fanficwriter1966
fanficwriter...
Offline Send Email
Aug 19, 2008
7:23 pm

First of all,  wow.  I joined this group almost a year ago, and this is as lively a debate as I've seen thus far.  Second, thank you to all who support...
AKALP
lauraprice35
Offline Send Email
Aug 21, 2008
12:07 am
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help