Search the web
Sign In
New User? Sign Up
a_film_by
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
Real people. Real stories. See how Yahoo! Groups impacts members worldwide.

Best of Y! Groups

   Check them out and nominate your group.
Having problems with message search? Fill out this form to ensure your group is one of the first to be migrated to the new message search system.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
My Favorite Year: 1932   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #1675 of 48867 |
Re: [a_film_by] Re: My Favorite Year: 1932

Gloria Stuart shows up again in The Prisoner of Shark Island. She was
interviewed on line re Titanic in 1997 by Cinemania:

Gloria Stuart: The first picture I made with John Ford, Air Mail  he
was not a great big famous director [then]. He was hired independently
at Universal. And I think the Yiddish word is potchkeh [time-wasting] 
it was really a potchkeh picture, low-budget and everything. James
Whale's movies were the only ones I made at Universal of quality,
distinction, talent.
Cinemania: Ford's The Prisoner of Shark Island, which you made for Fox,
is a superb film.
Gloria Stuart: It was a major production, but I didn't have much to do
in that. In both Ford pictures I don't remember what I call directing.
He was very good with the camera. I don't remember much dialogue between
John and actors. He always had top scripts and top actors. It's very
hard to go wrong that way.

***

To which I'll add that I much prefer Lillian Bond in Air Mail. Patricia
Neal was also unappreciative of Ford (or Vidor or Sternberg), not to be
compared with Martin Ritt: there's a REAL director. Ford and those
others were good with other things, like lights.

It was fun to have a sleeping bag in Algeria! One could sleep anywhere,
anytime.
Bette Davis is also good in 1932 in George Arliss's Man Who Played God
(if you like Arliss, and I love him!) and Wellman's So Big. I think
Wellman's early 30s pictures are fabulous and I suspect influenced
mid-30s French cinema.

>
> I need to see it again, but I remember feeling that the
> film was rather shockingly dark, and certainly not "typical
> of action genres" (and Karl Freund's lighting seemed
> surprisingly dark, but in an expressive way: very Murnau).
>
> --Bob Keser

Very Murnau. Very moods. I wrote a long comparison between it and Only
Angels Have Wings; I much prefer Ford.

For me personally, American Tragedy is as good as anything von Sternberg
did (I'm told we're supposed to say von Sternberg, and that he's a V not
an S, regardless of European usage) -- for the first half. His autobio
gives a misleading portrait of himself as disinterested in social
problems, but they're all there in this movie, and his sympathies are
with the proletarian, in contrast to George Stevens in his remake.
http://www.sensesofcinema.com/contents/01/19/sternberg.html

Tag Gallagher.





Tue Sep 2, 2003 2:51 pm

tagtagta
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #1675 of 48867 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

... Oh, she was a unique personality (and very beautiful) in those films (she's makes a really charming companion for Dick Powell in the "I'm Going Shopping...
Robert Keser
rfkeser
Offline Send Email
Sep 2, 2003
2:19 pm

Gloria Stuart shows up again in The Prisoner of Shark Island. She was interviewed on line re Titanic in 1997 by Cinemania: Gloria Stuart: The first picture I...
Tag Gallagher
tagtagta
Offline Send Email
Sep 2, 2003
5:30 pm

... he ... independently ... wasting]  ... Not much of an auteurist, is she? Interviews with actors can be valuable (I liked Patrick McGilligan's interview of...
Robert Keser
rfkeser
Offline Send Email
Sep 2, 2003
10:18 pm

... Yeah, for me too. The courtroom scenes don't always sustain the amazing mood of the first part of the film, but the good stuff is so incredibly good that...
Dan Sallitt
sallitt1
Offline Send Email
Sep 2, 2003
5:45 pm

Haven't had a chance to see An American Tragedy in decades. Would love to see it again! The scene that sticks in memory is the factory. It showed Sternberg's...
MG4273@...
nzkpzq
Offline Send Email
Sep 2, 2003
11:53 pm

... I tried to summarize his colleagues' opinions on this score at the end of my book. Consensus was there was no consensus, no method, no consistency. No,...
Tag Gallagher
tagtagta
Offline Send Email
Sep 3, 2003
4:17 am

"Their excuse was that nobody knows who he is." That is so fucking disgusting I don't know where to begin. But burning their offices to the ground might be a ...
David Ehrenstein
cellar47
Offline Send Email
Sep 3, 2003
4:37 am

... Fascinating stuff, Tag, not least because I'm in the midst of planning a course for Facets called "Making Marlene Dietrich" which proposes studying the...
Robert Keser
rfkeser
Offline Send Email
Sep 3, 2003
4:38 am

"I Was Born But..." is sublime. Marlene is thinking about Travis Banton. And of her own beauty. Always. Maximillian Schell's film makes that clear. ... ...
David Ehrenstein
cellar47
Offline Send Email
Sep 3, 2003
4:49 am

... His film is going to be the (somewhat grim!) finale of the course, but I prefer to think of it as an astringent ending, a kind of memento mori. --Bob Keser...
Robert Keser
rfkeser
Offline Send Email
Sep 3, 2003
4:55 am

... Sounds good! I'm sorry I haven't seen the Dietrich expos in Berlin (or Berlin). ... Anatahan is narrated in retrospect and there are flashbacks at the...
Tag Gallagher
tagtagta
Offline Send Email
Sep 3, 2003
5:17 pm

I am in complete agreement that "Song of Songs" is terrible, but it's quiteunjust IMO to then say "And, finally, this is why Mamoulian is boring: because he ...
David Ehrenstein
cellar47
Offline Send Email
Sep 3, 2003
5:29 pm

You're right to object. And I apologize. First, that was the second half of a one-paragraph entry (so I give you the whole thing now). Second, I was obliged to...
Tag Gallagher
tagtagta
Offline Send Email
Sep 3, 2003
5:50 pm

How do you solve a problem like Mamoulian? (Okay, not as good a pun as The People Against Oharu!) The factor that turns me against Mamoulian is his arbitrary...
Robert Keser
rfkeser
Offline Send Email
Sep 4, 2003
4:56 am

And, of course, I'm the one who brought up the ... One reason LOVE ME TONIGHT works so well is that the various stylistic tricks (with sound, camera movement,...
jaketwilson
Offline Send Email
Sep 5, 2003
3:32 am

I agree with everything Robert Keser writes about Mamoulian. I think we're saying much the same thing. I also like CITY STREETS. Thanks for the correction...
Tag Gallagher
tagtagta
Offline Send Email
Sep 4, 2003
3:00 pm

By all means, feel free to waddle (!) However, my comment was intended to correct your self-criticism that you were "simply (ab)using Mamoulian in order to...
Robert Keser
rfkeser
Offline Send Email
Sep 4, 2003
4:17 pm

So you agree with my analysis of Mamoulian, but you like what I dislike -- that the tricks overpower the characters...? Tag....
Tag Gallagher
tagtagta
Offline Send Email
Sep 5, 2003
4:06 am

... dislike ... Well, I think his approach works in that particular case. The point isn't the technical tricks themselves so much as the way they make the...
jaketwilson
Offline Send Email
Sep 5, 2003
5:37 am

... I hope I succeeded... (It's easy to say why one doesn't like something. Damn difficult to say why one does.) ... Me too. It was his wife and son who said...
Tag Gallagher
tagtagta
Offline Send Email
Sep 5, 2003
1:53 pm

... and ... asked; ... That proves it: never ask!! (Did you interview them in person, or was it an exchange of letters?) I pointed out that usage is different...
Robert Keser
rfkeser
Offline Send Email
Sep 5, 2003
6:46 pm

... Phone. Separately. Several times. ... Lots of people dissed JVS. Lots of people didn't. I have a copy of an unpublished int with Brooks (part of which...
Tag Gallagher
tagtagta
Offline Send Email
Sep 6, 2003
1:22 am
 First  |  |  Next > Last 
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help