WTF with plugins and rendering in Avid. Is multi-thread/multi-
processor really that difficult? Who do we blame for this? You know
what: I really don't care who's fault it is! It's time for this
silliness to go away.
I don't know how this compares to FCP, but I'm totally sick of having
only one core on my 8-core CPUs working. When we switched to Mac, we
gained just enough power and speed to start using plug-ins
I've become addicted to digital filters- DFT, or rather Tiffen, is
especially helpful in making sucky footage not quite so sucky. Boris
has some nice ones, too, if a little funky. I won't even spend the
money on Saphire, for fear they'll actually work, and I'll be
rendering all night, every night. We're not talking silly 'cartoon'
effects or whacked-out-modern-digital-switcher-wipes, either... just
noise reduction, film grain, and filters that the DP could have used
in front of the lens in the first place (but I'd rather he didn't,
since he couldn't even be bothered to match his cameras, so imagine
what it would look like if he/she were tossing filters on there!)
This is just stupid. Fix it. Use the whole computer. Why should it
take 30 minutes to render a 3 minute clip. What is this ABVB? Come
on! This mac's a supercomputer, yet I can render out RED .R3Ds to HD
faster than I can render a simple Soft/FX.
I refuse to buy any more filters until someone addresses this
stupidity. Hire some code wizards, and don't put bureaucracy in front
of them. Snow Leopard? I can wait for that, but somehow I'm guessing
it's not the answer.
Please, please, please, make our filters render at a reasonable
speed. They don't have to be real time... I gotta eat and type
email... but, crap, at this rate, I could have multiple systems and
still have downtime!
And, while you're at it- what's up with color grading in HD? Is it
just Mac, or is the Symphony clunky regardless of the HD? We're doing
more and more HD, and the difference between HD and SD in symphony
color, at least on my mac, is seriously noticeable. I don't remember
it bothering me before - maybe it's the newer builds? Spinning beach
balls and little stop watches. Uhg. Is that what I paid extra for?
Grrrrrrrrrr.
gh
----------------------------------------------------
Greg Huson
Secret Headquarters, Inc
Post Production / Production
Culver City, CA
323 677 2092
323 677 2096 F
www.DigitalServiceStation.com
greg (at) SecretHQ.com
www.SecretHQ.com
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
WTF with plugins and rendering in Avid. Is multi-thread/multi- processor really that difficult? Who do we blame for this? You know what: I really don't...
"I don't know how this compares to FCP, but I'm totally sick of having only one core on my 8-core CPUs working." ... Greg, I can tell you its not the same in...
Qmaster doesn't have anything to do with plug-ins in the editing application itself, I'm pretty sure. Even FCP doesn't allow for 'background' rendering... or...
George, George, George, Please tell me you're not serious when you write: "although FCP is more fun and experimental... it loses renders." That's so ver 5.5!...
@ Greg: I feel your pain. Are you on MC 3.x? I'm wondering if the effects you're using have to be re-coded to be an ACPL-based effect? If that's the solution,...
Ben, Try this: Let's say your project has 4 tracks and you want to solo video TRK 3 with OUT losing renders. Hit "T" (for track) once, and the cursor turns...
Great tip Mark. Thanks. I'd often wondered about a workaround for this since it seems like a real weakness in FCP. ... [Non-text portions of this message have...
I'm with Mark here on FCP behavior. Soloing tracks and undoing a render is undesirable but at this point it falls in the realm of operator error. First, you do...
Mark, I must be missing something simple, but this is not working for me. Ctrl-B disables selected tracks, timeline becomes unrendered. Ctrl-B enables the...
Helgi, In FCP... I'm not sure what Mark was thinking about specifically, but Ctrl-B disables any highlighted clips. If you have a 4-layer build and want to...
This whole thing in FCP of having to rerender an entire stack when any change is made is a PITA. At the time when it was just for editing DV footage, it made...
Terry, Agreed. Management of render files is a weak point in FCP. On the other hand, try flying in series of 3Kx3K stills on a Symphony or MC. Oh wait - you...
... <<On the other hand, try flying in series of 3Kx3K stills on a Symphony or MC. Oh wait - you can't - at least not without jumping through hoops.>> That's...
... Terry, With SD I would agree with you, but not in HD. I'm actually doing that even as we speak and they look very good. For whatever reason scaling in HD...
In Avid you have good solutions for managing stills in both BCC and Avid FX. These are part of every system sold - Mac & PC. Doesn't seem like that big of a...
I need to find stock footage of hurricanes striking Haiti last fall. I've e-mailed several stock places this week, and a couple of aide organizations who have...
Especially with Vista 64 bit and have more than 4GB of RAM. It is very responsive. BTW Mark - early versions of 6.x had render connecting issues (mostly ProRes...
I agree with Dom here, 64 bit seems to help spread the load to all cores on various processes including transcoding. I think i have seen in the new(ish) 3.5.1...
I agree with you Greg. I noticed the other day when I was rendering (not even 3rd party plugins) and most of my cpu cores were sitting idle. Let's harness...
For whatever reason Sapphire effects tend to render faster than Boris. Not all, Motion Blur takes forever. Also a sequence with Boris effects tends to be a...
Greg tried the Symphony on PC at the Editors' Lounge last night and saw that it was snappy in the color correction. This is not what he is seeing on Mac. I'm...
Olivier, You never have actually cut on an 844, have you? Bouke (who likes a lot of the features already present in M100 2.0 that are still absent in MC) ...
Bouke, Yes, I cut a 1 hour TV show pilot on it. I wasn't fond of it for cutting long-form, but I like the way it handled effects and layering for graphics and...
FWIW, after my original rant on this issue, I discovered the biggest contributor to my problem was the specific plug-ins I was using. The DFT (now tiffen)...
Wow, I've never used the Tiffen plug-ins, but if switching to boris causes a "dramatic" savings in render time, "tiffen" must be the latin word for "glacier"! ...
We have 8 workstations. Sapphire, at 2800 per seat, isn't in the cards. When a client demands them, and books a big enough job... maybe. Boris is included...
... <<We have 8 workstations. Sapphire, at 2800 per seat, isn't in the ... Greg, If you decide to et them, ask for the dongle for 400 bucks. That way you only...
Terry and Greg, Sapphire has phased out the dongle, but I think they now have a software activation plan similar to Adobe and Avid. Load up all the systems,...